The New York Yankees conducted their business at the non-tender deadline, keeping everybody (yes, even Clarke Schmidt at $4.5 million) except pitchers Fernando Cruz and Luis Gil. For now, that saved them about $4.5 million. We'll see what happens in the coming weeks since it's possible one or both return on lesser deals.
Leading up to Friday's deadline, however, some wondered if the Yankees would call the Twins and ask about Royce Lewis. The oft-injured utility infielder and former No. 1 overall pick was due $5 million in arbitration, which made it seem like the Twins were ready to move on after so many letdown seasons.
And they did. Except they made a deal with the Dodgers. Minnesota sent Lewis to Los Angeles in exchange for failed top prospect Bobby Miller and 19-year-old catcher Francisco Espinoza. The rich get richer (and more creative). The Yankees sit back, retain former players, and then wait the rest out.
Now, you might be saying, "Thomas, you just wrote about how bringing back Jonathan Loaisiga was a mistake because of his injuries and inconsistency, so why would you lobby for Lewis in any capacity?" And that would be a good point. But the two are very different players.
Right-hander Bobby Miller and catcher Francisco Espinoza are heading back to the Minnesota Twins as the return in the trade that sent third baseman Royce Lewis to the Los Angeles Dodgers, a source tells ESPN.
— Jeff Passan (@JeffPassan) November 20, 2026
Why didn't Yankees trade for former Twins' No. 1 pick Royce Lewis?
For one, Loaisiga is entering his age-32 season and has had only two successful/fully healthy MLB campaigns. Not to mention, paying $9 million a year for an extremely volatile reliever is a risky investment for a Yankees bullpen that cannot afford it. Don't forget, the Yankees employed Loaisiga for eight seasons and watched him melt down or not contribute. They already knew what they had there.
As for Lewis, yes, he's a walking injury. He's never been fully healthy for an entire season. He's been a disappointment even as he's seen more action on the field the last two seasons. But we were talking about a depressing asset the Twins wanted to get rid of. This wasn't paying top dollar for somebody who uncharacteristically had a stellar contract year. The comparable Yankees trade here would've been Gil (though he was a former Twin so we doubt they would've taken him back) and your choice of an unranked prospect. All we're saying is that it would've cost nothing.
Then there's the reality that anything is better than Ryan McMahon. Yes, even a platoon of Lewis playing 94 games and somebody else. That makes the Yankees a better team right off the bat.
The Yankees are faced with limited targets to creatively solve their infield problems. Lewis' versatility (he can play first, second or third) could've given them options with uncertainties at second and third for 2027. The injury risk is real and there was a good chance he derailed their plans in some capacity, but that's why they have someone like Jose Caballero, who can fill in on the fly without serving as a detriment. It wouldn't have been the perfect acquisition. It wouldn't have been the most impactful – not even close. But it would have been different and intriguing. It would've been a wildly more creative trade than almost anything the Yankees have made in recent seasons. And if it didn't work out, there was no attachment. Lewis is controllable through 2028 and could've been non-tendered next year if he failed miserably. But if he succeeded? Another year of Brian Cashman's favorite: team control.
Where were the Yankees here? We can only hope they have grander plans in place before the lockout because this feels like a huge miss given what was laid out in front of them.
