When news broke late Thursday night that the New York Yankees had signed Jonathan Loaisiga to a two-year deal, everybody was waiting for additional confirmation. Sports anchor Levi Luna reported the news, and though he ended up being correct, it was largely only regarded as a rumor at the time.
Then, on Friday morning, it was confirmed by ESPN's Jorge Castillo as well as Joel Sherman of the New York Post. It's a two-year contract with an option for a third year. And though we've been trying to stay positive this offseason, such a transaction only further erodes faith in this front office.
The Yankees employed Loaisiga at the MLB level from 2018-2025. Across eight seasons, he appeared in just 193 games and finished with 4.2 WAR — most of which was accumulated during his stellar 2021 season (3.3). Outside of that one year, he was either injured or downright bad.
Not to mention, he's not a strikeout reliever. He's just another guy who induces a ton of ground balls for a defense that can't reliably field. How did that work out for Tim Hill in 2026?
There were plenty of other superior options in free agency, but as the Yankees do, they went with the familiar cost-effective option despite already learning a harsh lesson at least four times over.
Can confirm pending physical that the Yankees and reliever Jonathan Loaisiga have a 2-yr agreement with a third-year option. @leviluna21 1st
— Joel Sherman (@Joelsherman1) November 20, 2026
Yankees re-signing Jonathan Loaisiga shows they've learned absolutely nothing
Since Loaisiga became a full-time reliever in 2021, he's averaged just 37 games per season. He's only logged more than 48 innings twice. Now, he'll rejoin the Yankees for his age-32 and -33 seasons after the Yankees seemingly fooled themselves into thinking the right-hander's revival with the Diamondbacks was anything different from the lengthy track record laid right out in front of them.
What's funny is that Brian Cashman spoke to the media on Thursday night and did what he always does — hype up injured players! He said Fernando Cruz (torn UCL) is healthy and should be ready to pitch in 2027 and echoed the same for Clarke Schmidt, who has pitched in a total of 31 games over the last three years.
We'll reserve further judgment when the money is revealed for Loaisiga's contract, but this represents another version of the "run it back" Yanks since they already knew what they had in Loaisiga, he let them down, and they decided to get sucked back in for reasons beyond comprehension.
