The non-tender deadline is Friday, Nov. 20 at 5:00 p.m. ET, and it'll probably be another uneventful one for the Yankees. Typically, New York isn't saddled with non-tender candidates; either they are comfortable with the salaries or they don't employ too many players that need to be cut loose.
At first, many suspected a possible salary cap may have influenced what they'd do this offseason. The Yanks have nine arbitration-eligible players, but only one candidate they'll likely cut loose in Fernando Cruz.
It's a sad situation, but Cruz, who is expected to be a major liability after suffering a UCL injury and forgoing surgery, is a sunk cost at $2.3 million. Otherwise, the other eight players, though we can debate, really have no reason to be non-tendered.
The case to keep Clarke Schmidt and Luis Gil on Yankees after non-tender deadline
The Yankees have nine arbitration-eligible players this winter.
— Everything Yankees (@eyyankees) October 30, 2026
-Luis Garcia Jr. (11M)
-Clarke Schmidt (4.5M)
-Anthony Volpe (4M)
-Jose Caballero (3.7M)
-Heliot Ramos (3.2M)
-Ryan Weathers (3.1M)
-Austin Wells (2.6M)
-Luis Gil (2.3M)
-Fernando Cruz (2.3M)
Worth keeping an eye… pic.twitter.com/lg75DtRa3x
Say what you will about $4 million being owed to Anthony Volpe, but right now he's your starter at second base come 2027. We wouldn't say it's the best use of funds, but it hardly makes sense to send him packing unless it's a trade.
The others are self-explanatory. The gray area is where Schmidt and Gil come in. Should they be part of the Yankees' roster moving forward? Most would argue no. And we'd agree. Schmidt has given them far too many headaches with injuries and Gil, similarly, fell off a cliff following his 2024 Rookie of the Year campaign.
That said, just because they aren't of use to the Yankees doesn't mean another team wouldn't find value in their abilities. Schmidt at $4.5 million and Gil at $2.3 million, given their upside, are assets to small market teams looking to build a pitching staff on a budget. Schmidt has made 32 starts in a season before and Gil's velocity could make him a promising bullpen reclamation project. Or maybe he becomes a viable starter again. We've seen crazier things happen.
Dustin May just signed a three-year, $52.5 million contract with the White Sox. Most capable starters are making somewhere in the $15 million AAV range. You've seen the relief market, too. Pitching is not cheap, even if the candidate isn't exactly a home run addition. That's what makes Schmidt and Gil attractive in this exercise. They're low-risk, high-reward. Schmidt's a free agent after 2027. Gil is controllable through 2028. Both have shown previous success.
We're not saying it's easy, but as GMs look to build a semblance of a roster before transactions are locked come Dec. 1, Schmidt and Gil should generate some interest from pitching-needy teams unwilling to spend amid the uncertainty (or those simply looking to fortify around the margins).
