For New York Yankees fans, Dustin May has simply been a reason to make fun of the Boston Red Sox. Boston took one of the key components of the Rafael Devers trade, outfield prospect James Tibbs III, and swapped him with the Los Angeles Dodgers for May's services at the 2025 trade deadline. For their troubles, they'd get 28 1/3 innings of 5.40 ERA ball.
Tibbs III would go on to put together a historic campaign in Triple-A, becoming the first hitter since 2005 to record 100-plus RBIs, walks, and runs in a single season, while batting .287/.409/.532 with 30 dingers. Ouch.
May takes on greater significance for the Yankees and their future now. The 29-year-old right-hander, who began his year with the St. Louis Cardinals before being traded to the World Series Champion Milwaukee Brewers, just signed a three-year, $52.5 million contract with the Chicago White Sox.
White Sox, RHP Dustin May reportedly agree to 3-year deal, per multiple reports including @MLBNetwork insider @JonHeyman. pic.twitter.com/rFX2ZSidQy
— MLB (@MLB) November 17, 2026
That's after a season in which he put up a 4.70 ERA over 31 starts and 145 2/3 innings. In the playoffs, May made five appearances and recorded a 5.73 ERA. In 2025, he made 23 starts, threw 132 1/3 innings, and posted a 4.96 ERA. From 2021-2024, he tossed a total of 101 innings while dealing with a variety of injuries.
If a guy like that gets $17.5 million annually, the free-agent starting pitching market is going off the rails. It makes us wonder what the value of actual mid-rotation arms with team control would be on the trade market now, which naturally brings us to Will Warren and Ryan Weathers.
Dustin May's contract will only help the trade value of Yankees starters Will Warren and Ryan Weathers
We saw last season, in part with the deal that brought Weathers to the Bronx, that controllable starting pitchers are worth their weight in gold on the trade market. It's why we believe that the Yankees should take advantage of their wealth of starters and shop Warren and/or Weathers to solve other needs on the roster, like second or third base.
Weathers has similar durability concerns to May, but he's been a better pitcher of late, posting a 3.60 ERA in 2026 and a 3.67 ERA overall since 2024. With two more years of team control and a projected arbitration number of $3.1 million for 2027, he still holds a lot of value despite the injury issues.
Warren might be even more valuable. While he's been frustrating to Yankees fans at times, Warren is durable, making 33 starts in 2025 and 32 appearances (29 starts) in 2026. His 3.92 ERA this year was significantly better than May's results, and he fits the role of a mid-rotation innings eater.
Warren doesn't hit arbitration until next offseason and won't be a free agent until after the 2030 season. That control, combined with his durability and performance, comes together to create an incredible value proposition.
There are plenty of teams with infield surpluses and rotation needs. The poster child is the Houston Astros, who have both Jeremy Peña and Isaac Paredes on the trade block, a dire need for starters, and not much wiggle room in their budget. Then there's a small-market club like the Athletics, who could move 24-year-old shortstop Jacob Wilson in exchange for quality pitching.
Those are just two examples. Most teams in the market are looking for someone better than May, and many can't afford these crazy rates. That could leave the Yankees sitting pretty, and if they deal one of these young starters, they might get back even more than we originally thought.
