Skip to main content

Yankees seem like they’ll let Mets, Dodgers or Jays pay for problem they don’t need

They'll learn soon enough.
ByStephen Parello
Jul 3, 2026; Phoenix, Arizona, USA; Arizona Diamondbacks pitcher Jonathan Loaisiga against the Milwaukee Brewers at Chase Field. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images
Jul 3, 2026; Phoenix, Arizona, USA; Arizona Diamondbacks pitcher Jonathan Loaisiga against the Milwaukee Brewers at Chase Field. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Bullpen help is a priority for the New York Yankees, and might be the top priority the club has at this juncture in the offseason. That will lead to a lot of stones being turned over, but there are some that the Yankees should know what is underneath without putting in the effort to examine what's beneath the surface because they've been there and done that.

That's why we were shocked that New York was considering a reunion with Jonathan Loaisiga (a report that was confirmed again Tuesday by NJ.com's Randy Miller). Sure, the 32-year-old is coming off a stellar year in which he posted a 2.42 ERA over 67 innings, but the Yankees have seen this before. In 2021, Loaisiga recorded a 2.17 ERA over 70 2/3 innings. The Yankees would then chase that dragon for the next four seasons, despite a ton of injuries and poor performance along the way.

Fortunately, it seems as if Brian Cashman has come to his senses. Jon Heyman reported that the Mets, Dodgers, Phillies, and Blue Jays are the frontrunners for Loaisiga's services, while noting that the Yankees are focused elsewhere. That's some very good news, and we can only hope Miller's report is an attempt by the Yankees to try and reunite with Loaisiga on the cheapest possible terms.

Yankees should know not to be blinded by shiny performances from non-elite relievers

Relievers are the most volatile players in the sport. There are several reasons for that. First, they play in smaller samples than other players, so their top-line stats are always going to have the potential to be skewed by a handful of good or bad performances.

Injuries also play a role, and with pitchers in general there's never a guarantee that they'll come back from a serious ailment as strong as they were before. This is also true of starters, but the degree to which a reliever relies on stuff versus a starter makes the margin for error smaller.

This brings up an important lesson. Paying serious money, as it appears that Loaisiga will get, for a middle reliever coming off an outlier year is usually a huge mistake. The chances of them replicating their performance, especially over a multi-year contract, are very slim.

For these reasons, New York should also be cautious about reuniting with Paul Blackburn this offseason. Paying the veteran right-hander $2 million and engineering his breakout is one thing, but giving him $10-plus million per season for multiple years would be a mistake.

The Yankees would be better off focusing on the upper-echelon talents like David Bednar, Adrian Morejon, and Alex Vesia to fill out the high-leverage spots in the 'pen, and then worry about developing the next breakout arm internally.

Following this path would not only mitigate risk, but also allow the club to more effectively utilize its resources. The good news is that many of the teams that are going after Loaisiga are Yankees rivals. Let them make the mistake, and then reap the rewards when he implodes. It looks like Brian Cashman has had a moment of sanity, and that's exactly what he will do.

Add us as a preferred source on Google