Skip to main content

Yankees could steal 2 prizes from Reds, Guardians if non-tender predictions come true

What a bounty!
ByAdam Weinrib
Cincinnati Reds v Toronto Blue Jays
Cincinnati Reds v Toronto Blue Jays | Mark Blinch/GettyImages

Whose escalating salaries will the New York Yankees either attempt to trade or decide to shuck off their payroll ahead of the non-tender deadline on Friday? Clarke Schmidt and Luis Gil are the leaders in the clubhouse.

If they're able to make moves, that'll help them keep roster spots warm for the upcoming free agent class — who'll either sign between Nov. 20 and Dec. 1 or ... sometime in March? It'll also potentially allow them to welcome some of the recent wounded onto the friendly confines of their 40-man roster, depending on what they're willing to pay. According to MLB Trade Rumors' projections, a number of very intriguing candidates might hit the open market on Friday, and a few of them fit the Yankees' specifications almost exactly.

These candidates come in many varieties. Want to plunder the Red Sox and their Summer of 2026 magic? You might be able to bring in Andruw Monasterio or Jahmai Jones, or possibly even Romy Gonzalez, all of whom could help flesh out the Yankees' bench. Odds are they'd be less magical in the Bronx, but you never know.

Remember when "Royce Lewis loves Derek Jeter" was a prevailing narrative any time the Twins' emergent top draft pick came to play the Yankees? Nowadays, Lewis is a shell of his former pre-debut self, rarely available but still showing flashes. Would the Yankees be willing to essentially swap Schmidt's salary out for Lewis' ~$5 million, banking on him being reinvigorated and approaching the 2023 version of himself (.309 average, .921 OPS) instead of the 2026 version (.227, .667)?

Of the myriad names who could shake loose, two seem to make the most sense for the Yanks: Matt McLain of the Cincinnati Reds and Jo Adell of the Cleveland Guardians.

Yankees could consider non-tender candidates Matt McLain, Jo Adell

Both men have significant prospect pedigree, but are at very different places in their careers.

Last trade deadline, the Yankees needed an outfielder who could mash left-handed pitching, defensive concerns aside. They chose Heliot Ramos and his additional years of control, while Adell propelled the Guardians to the ALCS. Non-tendering him would be a slap in the face after they won the trade so handily and he neatly filled his role, but a nebulous floating ~$9.5 million charge will do that to a small-market team sometimes. That's also pretty rich for the Yankees' blood, but if they move on from some combination of Ramos/Luis Garcia Jr./Spencer Jones, maybe he'd fit nicely.

McLain, like Lewis, seemed destined for greatness after his MLB debut, living up to his first-round pedigree in the Queen City. He posted 3.6 bWAR and a 127 OPS+ in 2023, finishing fifth in the Rookie of the Year race. Regrettably, he was halted in his tracks the next spring, suffering a torn labrum in camp and missing the entire season after surgery. His bat has never recovered its across-the-board potency, but ... he had a .777 OPS against left-handed pitching last season. While he was putrid offensively on the year, he would be a strong situational fit on the bench of a better team than the Reds.

Will the Yankees move on from Anthony Volpe? Only if they can leverage him into something they need more. Nevertheless, McLain showed more progress last season at Volpe's supposed strength, even in a down year overall.

Even if they don't go for either of these two, expect the Yankees to shuffle around a few cogs as the week wraps up.

Add us as a preferred source on Google