Skip to main content

Yankees make pair of depressing decisions, non-tender 2024 Rookie of the Year Luis Gil

Depressing reality, my old friend.
ByAdam Weinrib
World Series - Los Angeles Dodgers v New York Yankees - Game 3
World Series - Los Angeles Dodgers v New York Yankees - Game 3 | Luke Hales/GettyImages

Hours after reportedly agreeing to a two-year deal with Jonathan Loaisiga that evoked nostalgia for a better era, the New York Yankees opened up a pair of roster spots with two decisions that did the exact opposite.

Less than 24 hours after describing the progress of Fernando Cruz's throwing program as he attempts to avoid Tommy John surgery that could (and likely would) end his career, Brian Cashman and Co. instead dropped the hammer down, non-tendering the reliever and saving themselves approximately $2.3 million.

They did the same with 2024 Rookie of the Year winner Luis Gil, which is ... I mean, that's an insane thing that just happened.

Oft-injured and clearly not on the same page with the Yankees' lab, Gil has been the opposite of a metrics darling, ever since he regressed midway through his ROY campaign. His fastball once bordered on elite, but once things slipped, the command issues that have always plagued him won out and rendered him largely ineffective. The Yankees clearly shopped him ahead of the non-tender deadline, and clearly didn't like what they found out. Instead of accepting the return, they shucked him loose instead, saving another ~$2 million.

Clarke Schmidt among Yankees protected ahead of non-tender deadline

Both decisions the Yankees actually made were emotional for different reasons. It's hard to believe Gil fell so far out of favor after his peak first half in '24. By the time he made a postseason start during the Yankees' pennant run that fall, he was largely unrecognizable.

Cruz fought hard to avoid the surgery that'll take him out through his age-38 season and loved being a Yankee. He'll ultimately probably succumb to the knife anyhow, and a minor-league pact to return to the Yankees and rehab cannot be ruled out.

The Yankees did not make today quite as emotional as they could've, though, opting to keep Clarke Schmidt around for his walk year after a TJ recovery and a season filled with setbacks. That will likely cost them $4.5 million, pending some form of future trade.

The Yankees' roster still has plenty of high-profile holes, but they answered a resounding question on Friday with a shuffle that fans just two years ago wouldn't have believed. Given the way he destroys them ... would anyone be surprised if Gil becomes the latest beneficiary of the Yanks-to-Sox pipeline? This is certainly a more inglorious end than the Kyle Tucker trade would've been.

Add us as a preferred source on Google