Skip to main content

Yankees stars Ben Rice, Cody Bellinger hit a predictable Silver Slugger wall in awards blowout

Welp. Got wonked.
ByAdam Weinrib
Tampa Bay Rays v New York Yankees - Game One
Tampa Bay Rays v New York Yankees - Game One | Ishika Samant/GettyImages

PICTURED: Cody Bellinger and Ben Rice pointing at one another, trying to determine who got obliterated harder in the 2026 Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger Award race.

Let's face it. 2026 was not the Yankees' year for offensive accolades. Cam Schlittler continued their BBWAA awards trend, giving them a winner in a major race for the fifth straight season (if it's not Aaron Judge MVPs, it's Schlitt and Gerrit Cole taking home the Cy Young). Annoyingly, they've never managed to line up a Cy year with a Judge MVP year, but that's a champagne problem.

This could have been a dynastic three-peat for the Yankees in the Silver Slugger offensive team category after wins in their AL Pennant season in 2024 and a surprising Juan Soto-less repeat in 2025. Unfortunately, they fell off the proverbial cliff without Aaron Judge, James Rowson left to become the San Francisco Giants' offensive coordinator (???), and that award went to the Houston Astros. 81-81 in your programs, Silver Slugger award winners in your cold, dead hearts.

The Yankees were only up for two awards, sans-Judge, with Bellinger among the outfield finalists (nine, count 'em, nine) and Rice locked up with ... Yordan Álvarez at DH, just a few days after his MVP win. If you can think of a more compelling reason to get Rice fitted for a first baseman's glove next season, I haven't heard it.

The outfield winners were Randy Arozarena (free agent, scary), Riley Greene (Tigers, annual occurrence), and Chase DeLauter (rookie, fun). Those three players' OPS+ marks? 148, 135, 131. Bellinger's? 113. It was an honor just to be nominated (and win the All-Star Game MVP award).

Cody Bellinger, Ben Rice must regroup after Silver Slugger shellacking

Bellinger is essential to the Yankees' operation, even without the hardware. When he goes down for any length of time, they lose a defensive wizard in left field and a sturdy contact bat. Rice's 41-homer breakout and all-too-brief playoff surge do not deserve to be cast aside — but, hey, that's what happens when there are often only two finalists and one winner. Yordan is Yordan. No shame in second place.

Both men will resume their integral roles in the Yankees' lineup, which should once again be among the best in baseball, when the curtain rises on the 2027 season (TBD). For now, though, their losses are the final exclamation point on the reality of '26: the Yankees' offense was an afterthought.

Add us as a preferred source on Google