Skip to main content

2026 Silver Slugger Predictions: Yankees rivals will clean up as Ben Rice, Cody Bellinger fall short

It's unfortunately pretty clear. But they had a nice run.
ByThomas Carannante
American League Division Series: New York Yankees Workout
American League Division Series: New York Yankees Workout | New York Yankees/GettyImages

The 2026 Silver Slugger Awards show will take place on Tuesday, Nov. 17 at 6 p.m. ET and will be presented by FanSided and Louisville Slugger on the Baseball Insiders YouTube channel. The New York Yankees have two finalists this year with Ben Rice at designated hitter and Cody Bellinger as one of the outfielders.

Sadly, it's a stacked field and netiher really stand a chance. Not to mention, the Yankees as a team were not nominated this year. Instead, the division-rival Tampa Bay Rays, the 81-81 Houston Astros, the playoff-less Twins, and the underwhelming Chicago White Sox got the nod.

Complete list of 2026 Silver Slugger Finalists, including Yankees' Ben Rice and Cody Bellinger

  • AL 1B: Pete Alonso (Orioles), Willson Contreras (Red Sox)
  • NL 1B: Jake Bauers (Brewers), Alec Burleson (Cardinals), Matt Olson (Braves), Rafael Devers (SF Giants)
  • AL 2B: Kody Clemens (Twins), Chase Meidroth (White Sox)
  • NL 2B: Brandon Lowe (Pirates), Brice Turang (Brewers)
  • AL 3B: Junior Caminero (Rays), Miguel Vargas (White Sox)
  • NL 3B: Alex Bregman (Cubs), Max Muncy (Dodgers)
  • AL SS: Kevin McGonigle (Tigers), Bobby Witt Jr. (Royals), Zach Neto (Angels)
  • NL SS: CJ Abrams (Nationals), Elly De La Cruz (Reds), Otto Lopez (Marlins)
  • AL OF: Wilyer Abreu (Red Sox), Randy Arozarena (Mariners), Cody Bellinger (Yankees), Jac Caglianone (Royals), Chase DeLauter (Guardians), Riley Greene (Tigers), Tristan Peters (White Sox), Chandler Simpson (Rays), Mike Trout (Angels)
  • NL OF: Pete Crow-Armstrong (Cubs), Corbin Carroll (Diamondbacks), Jackson Chourio (Brewers), Seiya Suzuki (Cubs), Fernando Tatis Jr. (Padres), Jordan Walker (Cardinals), James Wood (Nationals)
  • AL C: Dillon Dingler (Tigers), Carter Jensen (Royals)
  • NL C: Hunter Goodman (Rockies), Gabriel Moreno (Diamondbacks)
  • AL DH : Yordan Alvarez (Astros), Ben Rice (Yankees)
  • NL DH : Kyle Schwarber (Phillies), Shohei Ohtani (Dodgers)
  • AL UTIL: Sam Antonacci (White Sox), Ezequiel Duran (Rangers), Kevin McGonigle (Tigers)
  • NL UTIL: Jake Bauers (Brewers), Fernando Tatis Jr. (Padres), Sal Stewart (Reds)
  • AL TEAM: White Sox, Astros, Twins, Rays
  • NL TEAM: Cubs, Dodgers, Brewers, Nationals

Rice is going up against the AL MVP in Yordan Alvarez, who won the Triple Crown in 2026 and put up arguably the best season of a DH ever. Bellinger, though he had a good season, doesn't really stand a chance against Arozarena (who had a career year), Riley Greene (who overall had superior numbers), or even Jac Caglianone. It's hard to see a path to Belli winning.

Looking at the rest of the field, an Oriole or Red Sox will win at first base. Junior Caminero is probably going to beat Miguel Vargas. We'd probably guess Wilyer Abreu has a better shot than Bellinger in the outfield. One of the Astros or Rays will win the team award. And former Yankee Ezequiel Duran has appeared in the wild and we can't believe it.

Enjoy the show! It'll be a good one. But go into it as a baseball fan, not a Yankee fan. We don't think the outcome for the Bombers in 2026 will be favorable.

Add us as a preferred source on Google