The New York Yankees have made their first move of the offseason, adding a lefty reliever to a bullpen that is in dire need of reinforcements. No, it's not that lefty reliever; Adrian Morejon is still a free agent. Instead, the club agreed to terms with ... Tim Hill. Consider us sufficiently whelmed by the move.
There's actually some reason to believe that Hill, who was lights out up until May of this year, can bounce back in 2027. But either way, his $2.25 million salary isn't stopping the Yankees from making a much more impactful addition to the relief corps.
That brings us back to Morejon, who is the apple of many fans' eyes. The 27-year-old southpaw throws a sinker that reaches triple digits and is the kind of high-strikeout arm the unit has been missing. It would seem, qualifying offer and all, that he should be New York's top priority moving forward.
According to Michael Kay, people inside the Yankees organization "love" LHP Adrian Morejon.
— Yankees Worldwide (@NYYWorldwide) November 3, 2026
The Yankees displayed interest in Morejon during the trade deadline, and he's presently a free agent with a Qualifying Offer attached.
2.83 ERA | 2.37 FIP | 58% GB% | 107 SO | 86 IP pic.twitter.com/yRoYYXb6vu
But while Morejon is generating a tremendous amount of buzz, both inside Yankees circles and the league at large, the club would be better off considering his lesser-known teammate, Jason Adam. The reasons for this are multiple.
Yankees can build a more complete bullpen with former Padres reliever Jason Adam over Adrian Morejon
At the outset of free agency, the pundits expected Morejon to land a massive deal. MLB Trade Rumors predicted a five-year, $80 million contract for him, which is kind of insane considering he has just eight career saves. That would be one of the largest contracts ever given to a reliever, and the other guys who have gotten paid that handsomely have all been bonafide closers.
The notion that Morejon could land a wildly lavish deal was confirmed when the Atlanta Braves shockingly gave injury-prone setup man Evan Phillips a three-year, $35 million contract.
New York turning its attention from Morejon to Adam wouldn't mean that the club believes Adam is better, but that he could be part of a stronger bullpen unit overall.
At 35 years old, Adam would be looking at a shorter-term deal and one for significantly less money. Spotrac pegs his market value at one year, $8.7 million, though maybe in this accelerated market he gets a tad more. Either way, it will be a far cry from what Morejon will receive.
Adam isn't the same high-octane setup man, but he is a more than reliable presence in the middle innings. Over the past five years, he's posted a 2.98 ERA or better each season, and tallied an ERA under 2.00 in three of those campaigns.
There is some concern, as Adam dealt with injuries in 2026 that limited him to just 38 appearances and 34 1/3 innings. While he posted a 2.62 ERA, he saw his velocity decline and his strikeout rate fall from 25.9% in 2025 to 15.5% this year. However, if he's healthy, these numbers should rebound.
The main issue here is whether you want a top-heavy bullpen or one that is deep from start to finish. It's unknown whether it would be an either/or scenario between Morejon and re-signing David Bednar, but even in the best-case scenario where the Yankees land both, there is going to be a soft underbelly in the bullpen.
Injuries, volatility, and guys not living up to expectations are all concerns at any position, but are especially prevalent with relievers. To that end, having depth in the 'pen can be a very valuable resource.
Signing Adam over Morejon would allow New York the ability to bring back Bednar, plus add more. That could mean reuniting with Paul Blackburn again, or adding a similarly priced arm of which there are many in the market.
With Fernando Cruz out, the Yankees need as much depth as they can get, so a solid middle-innings performer like Adam, plus Blackburn and Bednar to go along with Brent Headrick, makes for a stronger overall unit than Morejon alone. At the end of the day, that's the point. One reliever can only give you so much, but a talented bullpen from top to bottom can be a game-changer. For that reason, passing on Morejon in favor of his more overlooked teammate (plus more) is the right path for Brian Cashman to take.
