The Yankees will wind up with a third baseman by the time the dust settles on this offseason. That much is obvious. Unless their pursuit of a third baseman is like their similarly obvious pursuit of a catcher or relief depth at last year's deadline, in which case all bets are off and I quit.
On Wednesday, they lost a clear and obvious target when, just a few hours after smoke emerged that Maikel Garcia might be available in exchange for pitching, the Mariners stepped to the front of the line and sent three MLB pitchers the Royals' way in order to get him.
Garcia, snubbed for the utility Silver Slugger win after his breakout 2025 season in favor of Zach McKinstry (who the Yankees might get instead!), was the best player exchanged in the deal. Relief prospect L.P. Langevin, a truly elite K-getter in the minors, might be the second-best, depending on your view of Bryce Miller's longball problem. Regardless of whether the Royals should have preferred Will Warren or not, they did prefer the Mariners' package, and the Yankees were temporarily left out in the cold.
Who knows if they ever reached the "offer" stage, but Jon Morosi confirmed on Thursday that the Yankees did check in on Garcia as their search to render Ryan McMahon irrelevant continues.
The Yankees checked in on 3B Maikel Garcia prior to him being traded and are involved in the market for third basemen, per @jonmorosi pic.twitter.com/GbzgNzunXG
— Yankees Worldwide (@NYYWorldwide) November 19, 2026
Yankees must pivot quickly to safe (Casey Schmitt) or bold (Gunnar Henderson) trade options after missing on Maikel Garcia
By hook or by crook, the Yankees cannot afford to leave Ryan McMahon atop their third base depth chart when the lockout arrives in just over two weeks. They're going to have to eat plenty of money to eventually get him off the roster, but they're not going to have to worry about that part to replace him on the depth chart.
The best-case scenario is sliding McMahon into some type of approximate salary match trade, helping pay down the amount of money they'd owe to, say, Corey Seager. Obviously, McMahon won't get them all the way there, and they'll have to tack him on to an otherwise appealing prospect package. The only way he might go in the coming days is if he's glued to the side of a trade that works without him, but has complex financials.
The Yankees can worry about that later, though. Whether it's the power-hitting Schmitt who would do well to escape the confines of San Francisco, or Henderson, who would probably require the Yankees' Adley Rutschman package plus Dax Kilby (ducks), the time is now to do more than merely check in on the third base market. Maybe the Yankees prefer a Silver Slugger winner like Seager or Henderson over a snub who may have been a one-year offensive wonder.
