The New York Yankees have plainly telegraphed their interest in moving on from Ryan McMahon at third base. After years of being averse to eating money, they're willing and able to pay McMahon's way out the door, whether the price is right or not. In the corresponding move to upgrade third base, they're specifically looking to talk to someone who's desperate for pitching, which they have in abundance.
Ahead of the non-tender deadline and the offseason's early closing bell, two teams have emerged dangling trade chips that would fit the Yankees nicely. One of them — San Francisco's Casey Schmitt — is someone the Yankees entertained last summer, and would certainly pursue again. One of them — Kansas City's Maikel Garcia — is on a reasonable contract and one year removed from an All-Star campaign.
On Wednesday morning, both were available in exchange for starting pitching help, per ESPN's Jeff Passan. Ding, ding, ding.
A few hours later, Garcia was gone to the Mariners in a surprisingly massive package, headlined by Bryce Miller and featuring three MLB pitchers in total. That's a haul. A haul the Yankees probably should've have paid for an iffy offensive threat. And speaking of offense...
A career-high in home runs for Schmitty in 2026, and some of them were as clutch as they come 💥 pic.twitter.com/cqshhQBuNb
— SFGiants (@SFGiants) November 17, 2026
That sound you hear is Will Warren pulling up Zillow at warp speed.
Yankees have ample pitching to trade for Casey Schmitt after Maikel Garcia deal
The Yankees know Garcia's agitating prowess first-hand, as he bothered them immensely and beefed with Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Anthony Volpe during the 2024 playoffs (and resulting clashes between the two teams). The fear with Garcia is that he parlayed an exceptional season into a payday — 5.8 bWAR, 16 bombs in 2025 — but the contract is still reasonable (four years left of a five-year, $57.5M deal) and though his power dissipated last year, he was still above-average offensively (102 OPS+). We get why he cost what he cost, but that's a hefty ask. The Yankees can't afford to sacrifice all their pitching in one deal.
Schmitt is a more potent option, and it's actually somewhat surprising he wasn't dealt last summer (to the Yankees). The hard-nosed righty Giant hit 21 homers last season (119 OPS+) and is under team control through 2029. No matter who you preferred when you woke up this morning, the choice has been made for you.
Warren is the Yankees' most appealing trade option (durability, upside, two-plus years of effective MLB work to lean on), but the Yankees could also float Elmer Rodriguez (high-pedigree prospect) and Ryan Weathers (the breakout many have been waiting for last season, but injury risk still looms large). The Yankees have Clarke Schmidt and Luis Gil to flesh out any package if they move quickly, before the Day of the Non-Tender on Friday. They shouldn't be too hasty to cash in Warren — once you do it, he's gone, after all — but it'll be a surprise if all three of Rodriguez, Weathers, and Warren are on the active roster when the curtain rises on 2027, and it's tough to ask for a better fit than "upside third baseman" in exchange.
Now, Mariners, here's the real question: Is Brendan Donovan available as Garcia overflow?
