Yankees make emotional Oswaldo Cabrera decision we should've seen coming to activate Clarke Schmidt

The New York Yankees telegraphed the way they viewed beloved utility infielder Oswaldo Cabrera all season. Once an up-and-coming potential 20-homer bat who showed the ability to float between the infield and outfield and make a difference wherever he went, Cabrera transformed into more of a smiling placeholder over the past few years.

That didn't change the way his teammates viewed him, though. Every time he's been promoted, he's been integral to the clubhouse's attitude. When his ankle twisted into oblivion against the Mariners last season, the air was temporarily sucked out of the entire campaign.

That moment ended Cabrera's season and permanently changed his Yankees fate. In 2024, he was called upon to play an emergency first base during New York's World Series run after Anthony Rizzo's late-season injury. By 2026 spring training, he was an embattled soldier, returning to the field triumphantly, but without a defined role in either the present or future.

The stark reality is this: after his emotional comeback, the Yankees didn't pay him much mind this season. He was promoted in an emergency situation for three games, recording nine hitless at-bats (marred by a brutal appearance in extra innings vs. Detroit during the June/July swoon). Otherwise, he was in a separate bubble, cordoned off from his teammates fighting through a playoff race in Scranton, feeling very much like his 2025 exile.

And so, when we attempted to forecast a Clarke Schmidt roster move to get him off the 60-Day IL, we picked pitchers (Bradley Hanner, Michael Fulmer, Ryan Yarbrough). We probably should've seen the writing on the wall. Cabrera is the one who's been DFA'd - and he'll almost certainly be claimed by a team prizing versatility in the latter part of the season.

Yankees welcome Clarke Schmidt back with brutal Oswaldo Cabrera twist

Cabrera was last floated as a candidate for elevation when the Yankees instead turned to Anthony Volpe last week. Volpe's hot start has proven the validity of that comeback choice, which firmly sealed Cabrera's inevitable fate.

Schmidt has looked like a potential postseason weapon as his rehab assignment has dragged on. Cabrera? He's hitting .288 with a .790 OPS in the high minors this year, looking valuable for a team with aspirations of completing their roster picture for 2027. He's going to be coveted. But not by the Yankees. Hasn't been for a while now. And we should've seen that coming.

This surely wasn't easy. But it was surely inevitable.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow