Yankees' homegrown core is being disrespected in scorching takes after another playoff exit

It didn't take long for the mood around the Yankees to sour. The Rays swept them out of the ALDS, with some fans leaving Yankee Stadium chanting "Fire Boone!" and the loudest voices wasted no time calling for a full teardown. But before anyone lights the match, it's worth looking at who actually showed up in October. The players the Yankees drafted, developed and trusted with spots in the lineup were the ones who gave this team a pulse.

The Yankees' homegrown core delivered when it counted

Start with Cam Schlittler, a seventh-round pick out of Northeastern. In Wild Card Game 1 against the Red Sox, he carved through 6⅓ innings of two-hit ball with 10 strikeouts on 117 pitches in a 9-0 win. Then, even when the Rays chased him in the fifth inning of ALDS Game 2, with four Yankees errors helping produce half the runs against him, his response was, "I'm disappointed in myself." That kind of accountability is leadership beyond his years and the type of starter’s DNA you build around.

Ben Rice gave the offense its loudest moments. The 12th-round pick out of Dartmouth had four hits, two homers (including a grand slam) and six RBI in that Wild Card opener, then hit two more homers in the Game 2 loss to Tampa Bay. That made him the first player in Yankees history with two multi-homer games in a single postseason. His four homers through the team's first four postseason games tied Lou Gehrig (1928) for the second-most by a Yankee in that span.

Rookie George Lombard Jr., a 2023 first-rounder, kept pace at just 21 years old. He had three hits in his postseason debut and his first playoff RBI the next night. His defense in ALDS Game 2 was rough, but that's the price of learning in October, and the experience is worth something.

Then there are the two who've heard the most noise around their departure from New York. Austin Wells, a first-rounder in 2020, drove in two runs in Game 1 against Boston and added a sacrifice fly in Game 2. In ALDS Game 1, his eighth-inning double was the Yankees' only hit, though he ran through a stop sign and was thrown out at third. He also owned his mistake and took accountability afterward and acknowledging: "The risk was wrong."

Anthony Volpe, the 2019 first-rounder, tied Game 3 with an infield single, then hit a ball that looked like a game-tying homer before a fan-interference review turned it into a double. After the elimination, he didn't hide from the frustration: "At this point I don't even think motivated is the right word. I think it's just pissed off."

That's the makeup you want. Do these guys all have things to clean up? Of course. But a team that went through the postseason without Aaron Judge (another homegrown product in his own stratosphere) and still got this kind of production from its own system has a foundation.

What does it take for the Yankees to win with this group?

So where should the conversation go from here? Instead of tearing the core down, the fans should be positive about the development and the Yankees front office should find the veterans who complement it and strengthen the clubhouse.

Just look at the Dodgers. Kiké Hernández calls himself the "clown in the clubhouse" and says, "I'm in charge of checking guys." Mookie Betts has described Miguel Rojas as "the guy that kind of keeps us in order," the one who does the little things you don't realize you need until he does them. Neither is the reason you buy a ticket, but come playoff time, that kind of presence shows up loud, and those two are big reasons why the Dodgers are attempting a three-peat.

The Yankees already have the young talent. What they need now are leaders who can help that group handle the moments that tripped them up in Tampa, from the errors to the baserunning to the weight of another early exit. Aaron Boone said it himself: the team "did really good things this year, but ultimately not good enough."

The pieces to build around are already here. Find the right voices to go with them, and this group can turn October heartbreak into the foundation of something special.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow