Anthony Volpe has not had a great time in pinstripes. He was once the product of the hype that comes with being a top prospect of the New York Yankees and tabbed as the proper successor to Derek Jeter, which are admittedly nearly impossible expectations to live up to. As a result, Volpe has been battered and bruised, relentlessly analyzed by the media and incessantly criticized by fans on social media.
This isn't an Anthony Volpe apology letter, though. While it's been harsh, it's been his play on the field — years of stagnation — that has caused this level of intense scrutiny. He could have ended it with better play long ago.
To his credit, Volpe has never complained. He's taken it on the chin, and he's used the hostility as fuel. It hasn't really worked, but give him credit for trying. That's why it's strange, but also encouraging, for him to be the one to say exactly what Yankees fans want to hear after an embarrassing sweep at the hands of the Tampa Bay Rays in the ALDS.
"This is my fourth season, it's been far too many times having this taste in your mouth. At this point I don't even think motivated is the right word. I think it's just pissed off. There's too many chips added to your shoulder that it feels like enough's enough," Volpe said following the crushing defeat.
With so many of his teammates singing Aaron Boone's praises and trying to gloss over the fact that he failed and they failed, again, it was refreshing to hear someone get mad and call a spade a spade, even if it was an unlikely source.
Anthony Volpe could be the spark the Yankees need in 2027
The showing against the Rays was an embarrassment. Everyone should be angry. Very few players actually performed against Tampa, which is far too common an occurrence for New York under the bright October lights in recent years.
Yankees in 2026 ALDS:
— Katie Sharp (@SharpStats17) October 8, 2026
.130 BA
.192 OBP
.239 SLG
.431 OPS
Those stats are their lowest BA, OBP, SLG and OPS in any multi-game postseason series in franchise history
It feels like Ben Rice and, to a certain extent, Austin Wells were the only hitters who brought the bats with them to the ALDS. But quietly, Volpe had a great postseason in the few opportunities he was given to play. He went 3-for-7 with two singles, a double, a run scored, and an RBI over the two games he played.
In particular, Volpe came to play in Game 3. His hustle during his infield single in the bottom of the fourth allowed him to score the Yankees' second run to even the game at 2-2. Then, hejust missed hitting a game-tying homer by a couple of feet, but wound up with an RBI-double as a consolation prize. The fight was there, but he needed his teammates' help.
ANTHONY VOLPE'S GAME-TYING HOMER IS OVERTURNED DUE TO FAN INTERFERENCE 😳😱 pic.twitter.com/obDrEHsd6j
— TNT Sports U.S. (@TNTSportsUS) October 8, 2026
A few months ago, it looked as if the Yankees had passed Volpe by with the promotion of George Lombard Jr. and Volpe's subsequent demotion to Scranton. But now we might need to rethink things. Two games and a good quote don't erase four years of futility, but the mentality behind those words and the action on the field he put forth in Game 3 could be a catalyst for change.
It just so happens that the Yankees will have an opening. It would be crazy to see Jazz Chisholm Jr. come back this offseason, especially after he did and said all the wrong things. That means second base will be free and primed for the taking. We've seen enough from Volpe to know that the position can't just be handed to him, but if he wins a competition for the job and truly lets this most recent failure fuel him, he just might revitalize his career.
