It's been no secret this offseason that the Mets plan to make a serious run at Tarik Skubal. And for the Yankees, that's par for the course. Seemingly every winter, the team in Queens is chasing the same headliner as the team in the Bronx. Sometimes the Mets win, too. Just ask Juan Soto, who left the Yankees for Steve Cohen's record-setting 15-year offer two winters ago.
On Wednesday, though, this offseason's main feature, the Skubal sweepstakes picked up a new twist. ESPN's Buster Olney reported that the expectation among some involved in the negotiations is that the bidding will ultimately come down to the Mets and the Toronto Blue Jays. That puts the Yankees' biggest AL East threat squarely in the race for the best pitcher on the market.
The expectation of some involved in the Tarik Skubal negotiations: in the end, the bidding will pit the Mets vs the Blue Jays.
— Buster Olney (@Buster_ESPN) November 18, 2026
Why the Blue Jays' Skubal pursuit should worry the Yankees
Even thought here are no pitching issues in the Bronx, the Yankees have reportedly considered a run at Skubal themselves. ESPN's Kiley McDaniel listed them among the teams thinking about the two-time Cy Young winner. The Yankees led the majors in staff ERA in 2026, and a rotation of Gerrit Cole, Max Fried, Cam Schlittler and Carlos Rodón, with Will Warren and a returning Clarke Schmidt behind them, is as deep as any in baseball.
That's what makes the Skubal move interesting. Adding him in free agency would let Brian Cashman trade from that surplus to fix a lineup that went quiet in a three-game ALDS sweep by the Rays. Third base is the obvious hole. Ryan McMahon hit .213 with a .636 OPS this season and is owed $16 million in 2027, and the free-agent class offers little relief at the position. Swapping a starter for an everyday third baseman, then filling the rotation with an ace like Skubal, would be the most electric (in a good) way to address both problems.
Per Olney, now the competition for that ace includes a division rival that has stopped acting like a small-market club. The Blue Jays pushed the Dodgers to Game 7 of the 2025 World Series, signed Dylan Cease last winter and, according to ESPN's Jeff Passan, are exploring every avenue to improve this offseason. Toronto reportedly met with Skubal in California this week, one day after the Mets made their pitch.
If Skubal lands in Queens, the Yankees lose a major headline (and a really good pitcher) to their crosstown rival. If he lands in Toronto, they have to face him four or five times a year in a division that keeps getting harder. The Jays will have Skubal and Cease to match up with any Yankees' duo. The Rays' pennant this fall made it two straight years that an AL East team other than the Yankees or Red Sox reached the World Series.
The Yankees used to be the team that took the stars away from everyone else. If Toronto starts doing that too, the path back to AL East dominance will be an unpleasant uphill battle — something the Yankees have already come to learn over the last 15 years.
