Skip to main content

Yankees chasing Sonny Gray off Red Sox becomes official after bloated Twins deal

The contracts, they're weird!
ByAdam Weinrib
American League Wild Card: Boston Red Sox v New York Yankees - Game Two
American League Wild Card: Boston Red Sox v New York Yankees - Game Two | Elsa/GettyImages

The pre-MLB lockout frenzy is certainly not priced as if there will not be a 2027 season. So, if you're looking for positive signs, Sonny Gray's surprise Minnesota Twins contract is another one. If you're looking for negative signs, Rob Manfred just opened his gaping maw again and spewed out some more beef tallow.

The last time we saw Gray, the ex-Yankee who couldn't be more fired up to join the Red Sox last winter and has always hated the Yankees, even during those few weeks after he'd forced himself to the Yankees in a trade, he was blubbering in Boston's visiting clubhouse about a lack of trust. His departure seemed inevitable after being yanked early for Erik Miller in Game 2 of the Wild Card Series, but he tried to save face with some half-felt Boston compliments on the way out of town.

In reality? The simplest explanation was the correct one. Gray bolted Fenway as quickly as anyone else in baseball has this offseason, signing a two-year, $55 million with the Twins with an opt out after Year 1. Again, if Year 1 doesn't happen ... that's a bold price to pay for a contract that might not last beyond this upcoming campaign.

Most teams are acting like the Rule 5 Draft isn't happening, but most teams are also acting like 2027 is worth paying for.

Sonny Gray's Twins deal sends a crazier wrinkle into the market than Dustin May's contract

May made over $50 million across three seasons in Chicago for the type of inconsistent production that saw him largely minimized during the Brewers' World Series run. Gray went 18-5 with a 2.72 ERA, befuddling hitters to the best of his abilities in his single year in Boston, finishing fifth in the Cy Young race. He might make ~$28 million for one year, then reevaluate his retirement decision a second time and choose to walk away.

Will Warren's capabilities lie somewhere between the peaks of both of these men. He's got to be valued like an $18-20M AAV pitcher at this point, right? The more time passes, the bargaining chip-pier he gets.

For now, Yankees fans will have to take solace in the reality that they chased Boston's veteran leader away from them with a Game 2 defeat that left him questioning his foundation, nine months after boasting loudly about how excited he was to give the Bombers a taste of his vitriol. Minnesota seems like a better fit anyway, as well as another team the Yankees like seeing on the other side.

Add us as a preferred source on Google