Skip to main content

Predicting which Yankees prospects will be protected on 40-man roster ahead of phantom Rule 5 Draft

The New York Yankees might do some unnecessary labor this week.
ByAdam Weinrib
Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders v Columbus Clippers
Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders v Columbus Clippers | Diamond Images/GettyImages

The New York Yankees have until Tuesday, Nov. 17 at 6:00 PM EST to decide whether or not they'll be protecting any eligible prospects from the Rule 5 Draft, which is slated to occur next month. It will not occur next month; the MLB Lockout is coming at the tail end of the day on Dec. 1, whether we'd like it to or not. There's no escaping it. Perhaps the Rule 5 will occur when the lockout is broken. Perhaps it won't. No one knows, yet teams still aren't going to leave their potential stars exposed on the oft chance of a surprise change in tune.

Prospects are "eligible" to be stolen in the Major League Rule 5 after four seasons, if they were signed at age 19 or older, or five seasons, if they were signed at 18 or below. If they're swiped and spend a full season on the active MLB roster (or Injured List) of the team that claimed them, they're gone. If the team that stole them sends them down, they boomerang right back.

The scariest type of pitcher to lose is a potential bullpen arm. Teams of all kinds are typically skittish about committing to raw and unproven position players, but 'pen arms? Losing clubs will stash a live arm all day and not think twice about it. The Yankees have gotten a number of reliever types swiped over the years; Luis Torrens is really the only position player of note that their rivals were bold enough to nab. Hell, no one even took TJ Rumfield last season!

This year's eligibles are an interesting crop, with only one stone-cold lock. The Yankees' 40-man roster sits at 34 men (after the weekend's reported Tim Hill signing), and they'll need room for additional adjustments in the days to come (Paul Blackburn? David Bednar?). Without going crazy and filling up the whole roster to its limits, these are the Yankees' most likely protection decisions.

Yankees' 40-man roster forecast ahead of Rule 5 Draft protection deadline: Which prospects are safe?

Lock: Carlos Lagrange, RHP

The Yankees would've tried the flamethrowing Lagrange in a short relief role last summer if his shoulder had held up, and even flirted with doing so late in the season anyway. If healthy, he'll absolutely factor into the Yankees' plans in 2027. They won't think twice about elevating one of the top arms in their system to the 40-man.

Likely: Allen Facundo, LHP

Despite being far away from the majors, Facundo ranks as MLB Pipeline's No. 7 Yankees prospect, and can touch 99 after whiffing 148 men in 114 1/3 innings last season, across Single-A and High-A. The Yankees may weigh risk vs. reward here — is anyone really going to claim a still-erratic arm (78 walks) who should be two-plus years away from the majors in any logical world? Probably not ... but ... they'll probably err on the side of caution and protect him, too.

Realistically, the Yankees will consider using up to two more spots, putting them at 38 (with, again, reliever decisions looming in free agency). They probably won't go far beyond Lagrange and Facundo.

If they do, it'll be to protect Roderick Arias, their former bonus baby who finally broke out and showed a semblance of development last summer. When they added Marco Luciano to the 40-man a few weeks back, though, were they telegraphing that they believed Arias was redundant? Or were they ready to cut Luciano further down the line, if needed? Keep your eyes on reliever Eric Reyzelman as well, who has strikeout stuff and the velocity to match, but never seems to get seriously considered by the men upstairs. He'll likely be stolen if the Yankees do not protect him.

Of course, there's a chance the Rule 5 just gets balled up and thrown in the trash can anyhow. This year, more than ever, literally anything could happen.

Add us as a preferred source on Google