Yankees Rumors: Yamamoto edge over Mets, Wandy Peralta, Cody Bellinger

3 of 3

It's always difficult to tell whether the Yankees are genuinely "in" on a free agent's market or being used for leverage to drive up someone else's price.

In the case of Japanese right-handed phenom Yoshinobu Yamamoto, there is blessedly no gray area. The Yankees desperately want him. They've gone so far "in" they've deployed Brian Cashman to Yamamoto's turf; the Yankees' head honcho skipped Old Timers' Day to scout Yamamoto's no-hitter in person. New York's interest is very real. The only question left is whether they can outmuscle several other desperate franchises in an escalating market.

The Red Sox probably should be in, especially after declaring their intentions of remaking the rotation with two or three additions. The Mariners would be a logical fit. The Dodgers can't be counted out, pending post-Ohtani pivots. But, all fall long, the Yankees, Mets and Giants have registered the loudest interest.

Rumors about the Giants won't be outbid for their targets this winter, which feels right, coming off an offseason of being outbid for literally all of their targets (except Carlos Correa, who they ghosted on prom night). It feels impossible for the Mets to be outbid on ... anyone or anything. But, if the rumors are to be believed, those "in the know" believe that, while the Mets will be "all over him," the Yankees somehow will have the easier time securing his services, per Andy Martino of SNY.

Bidding hasn’t even started yet, but the strong early feel at GM meetings from people in the know is that Mets would have a tougher time landing him than Yankees. But both are in https://t.co/ozXIRw8Usf
— Andy Martino (@martinonyc) November 10, 2023

Yankees Rumors: Yanks in better position than Mets for Yoshinobu Yamamoto?

Is this something to do with the "Japanese superstars sharing a locker room" principle? Kodai Senga has reportedly been recruiting Yamamoto hard, so it doesn't seem he's aware of any rift. You could count the Red Sox out too, then. Hell, count 'em out on their favorite target Shohei Ohtani, while you're at it!

The reasoning why Cashman and Co. would have the inside track no matter how wild Steve Cohen gets is nebulous at best, but for now, we'll have to cling to these nuggets while we wait for the Yankees to declare their intentions in any capacity. We hoped Cashman's press conference would provide clarity. Instead, he pulled out a knife and threatened onlookers. What can you do?

Yankees Rumors: Wandy Peralta returns?

After the majority of analysts all but wrote off a Wandy Peralta comeback in 2024 and beyond, it seems like we might've gotten Frankie Montas'd again (aka the Yankees see things differently).

"Multiple sources" told Gary Phillips of the Daily News this week that the Yankees are interested in bringing Peralta back, though reports indicate an offer has yet to be extended in the lefty's direction.

The Yankees didn't supplement Peralta in the bullpen with any additional viable lefty options the past few years (whither Matt Krook?), and he's been an integral rubber band man for the past three seasons in the Bronx, serving in whatever role the team has needed. You want him back-to-back days? No problem; he'll pitch in all five games of an ALDS against Cleveland.

Now 32, though, Peralta spent the second half of 2022 fighting back regression. His FIP didn't match his ERA. His control/command had begun to betray him. He was more hittable than his surface numbers indicated. And yet ... the dam never broke. It felt like Peralta got lucky reaching free agency without a meltdown and would be able to cash in elsewhere.

Apparently, that "elsewhere" might look a lot like back home, and we'll just have to trust that the Yankees know what to expect moving forward.

Yankees Rumors: Favorites for Cody Bellinger?

Do you believe in Cody Bellinger? You want to, right? But you've seen this before. You've seen the Yankees overpaying to reach the top of the market on a player who's track record doesn't exactly consist of uninterrupted success.

Bellinger looked like a Hall of Famer with the Dodgers through 2020. Then, he spent two years in non-tender limbo before finally getting the axe. He popped his shoulder out during the 2020 postseason and never seemed to be able to get it back into the socket.

But the Cubs believed last winter, and they were right. The Yankees could've committed a single year to Bellinger. They could've been the ones to rehabilitate him (or they could've failed in their attempts to do so). But the Cubs reaped that reward, and now if the Yankees want Clay Bellinger's son's services, they'll need to commit nine or 10 years and upwards of $200 million.

According to Bob Nightengale this week, the Yankees are the incoming favorites for Bellinger, alongside the incumbent Cubs and those pesky Giants again. If the Giants want to lap the field for a star, the Yankees should allow them. The Bellinger-Cubs marriage, at least, worked; we have no idea what the pinstripes will do to him. Bellinger is objectively a talented baseball player, but so was Carlos Rodón and so was Frankie Montas and so was Sonny Gray.

If the price is right and the Yankees are willing to absorb it and keep building, taking as many bites as possible at the apple to extend Aaron Judge's prime, then go for it. But Bellinger will block the Yankees from finagling better fits. We know this. So take every "favorite" status with a grain of salt. This one still smells more like a leverage play than the Yamamoto talk.

manual

Home / Yankees Rumors