The New York Yankees took a massive step towards shoring up their bullpen when David Bednar decided to accept the qualifying offer and return to the Bronx. That's step one, but the Yankees cannot be done.
The bullpen still needs high-leverage arms, but it also needs depth throughout. New York isn't going to be able to slot in stars at every level, but getting high-upside arms will be paramount. That was the thought process behind last winter's Angel Chivilli trade, and while that move didn't pay huge dividends, Chivilli is still here and could break out.
Betting on that isn't a great idea, though, and more depth is needed. To that end, why not go after a higher-end version of Chivilli and target Philadelphia Phillies reliever Orion Kerkering? Kerkering is only 25, and has been the subject of trade rumors for some time. Those rumors are starting to heat up again, even though the right-hander is coming off a year in which he posted a 4.97 ERA over 58 innings.
Unlike Chivilli, though, Kerkering has had success in the past. In 2024, he was superb, putting together a year in which he threw 63 innings with a 2.29 ERA while striking out 28.8% of batters he faced and recording a 6.6% walk rate. 2025 was also a good year for him, but the cracks started to show. His ERA rose to 3.30, his strikeout rate fell to 24.4%, and his walks crept up to a 10.2% rate.
Kerkering is a Matt Blake special, throwing Blake's preferred pitch: the sweeper 42% of the time and pairing it with a four-seam fastball that averages 97.1 miles per hour. That's right up the pinstriped pitching guru's alley, and if he could reconfigure Kerkering, New York could have a rising young reliever under team control for three years on their hands.
Trading for Orion Kerkering would be a great next step, but it can't be the end of the Yankees' bullpen improvements
Aside from the arsenal, Kerkering has other things going for him. He posted an 85.7 miles-per-hour average exit velocity (97th percentile), 31.1% hard-hit rate (94th percentile), and 6.1% barrel percentage (75th percentile). Essentially, he generates a lot of soft contact.
What kills Kerkering is the walks. At 12.2% in 2026, his walk rate was a seventh-percentile performance. The reason that they've risen so high is the fact that he only gets whiffs at a slightly above-average clip, 26.1%, and rarely gets chases, coming in as a 25th-percentile performer.
The sweeper is the main culprit. Despite throwing it more often than any other pitch, it has a subpar 25.9% whiff rate. Batters only hit .192 against it, but they often weren't chasing it when he threw it as a putaway pitch. This is where Blake comes in.
If Blake can get Kerkering's sweeper back working and his strikeouts to rise while he maintains the excellent contact metrics, the Yankees could have a real weapon on their hands. If anyone can get that done, it's Blake, and given how Kerkering performed recently, he won't cost much in a trade.
That's all well and good, but the Yankees can't rely on a buy-low candidate being the only other addition to the bullpen. They need to pursue at least one more high-leverage arm, and then they can slot Kerkering into the middle innings. That way, they can build a truly strong unit, while having the requisite depth to weather injury or poor performance.
The Yankees had some serious injury luck in the 'pen last season. They can't expect that to continue in 2027. Depth is important. Buy-low candidates like Kerkering can provide that. But players in this tier need to be looked at through the depth lens first, rather than having their bounce-backs assumed.
