The qualifying offer deadline has come and gone. In total, two players accepted and five rejected within the last 24 hours. Jake Bauers technically rejected last week when he signed with the Boston Red Sox. That felt like a win for the New York Yankees, and they got another on Tuesday.
Closer David Bednar accepted the one-year, $23.15 million deal for 2027 (alongside catcher Ryan Jeffers of the Minnesota Twins), making him the highest-paid closer from an AAV basis ever. Edwin Díaz's $23 million from the contract he signed last year was the record-setter, up from Josh Hader's $19 million.
Some might think that's too pricey of a deal for Bednar, but the truth is that the Yankees can't afford to start from scratch in their bullpen. Bednar's been excellent since coming over in a trade with the Pittsburgh Pirates and has proven he can handle New York like most others can't.
No, this is not a repeat of the Trent Grisham situation, which just about everybody predicted would be some form of nightmare last year. Bednar has a career track record of succeeding in high-leverage situations.
Not to mention, Bednar accepting gives the Yankees some flexibility. For one, they can continue negotiating with the right-hander if they desire a multi-year pact. If not, they only need to navigate payroll contraints for 2027. While it's a hefty raise, plenty of other money just came off the books. The one thing they can't do is trade him until June.
Source: MIN C Ryan Jeffers and NYY RP David Bednar accepted the 1-year, $23.15M qualifying offer.
— Alden González (@Alden_Gonzalez) November 17, 2026
Not accepting: SEA OF Randy Arozarena, CHC OF Seiya Suzuki, PIT 2B Brandon Lowe, BAL SP Trevor Rogers, SDP RP Adrian Morejon.
Implications of David Bednar accepting qualifying offer from the New York Yankees
With the possibility of a salary cap looming, a salary of this magnitude does present a bit of a problem with so many other needs. The Yankees still need a third baseman, a backup catcher, more relief help, and a center fielder/fourth outfielder. Depending how you look at it, second base could be a need as well.
With Bednar's $23.15 million added to the fold, that puts the Yankees at almost $266 million in guaranteed payroll for 2027 (that's estimating all of the arbitration numbers too). Though MLB's recent CBA proposal kicks a possible cap down the road until 2028, we don't know what's going to come out of the negotiations. The proposed cap was $258 million, and right now the Yankees have an estimated $228 million committed for that year. The hope is that the current system stays in place with some minor tweaks.
Most importantly, however, is the fact the Yankees got their guy before transactions are expected to be barred by Dec. 1. Though there's still work to be done in the bullpen, it will be building around Bednar, which is much easier than finding another Bednar-type to anchor the unit and provide structure.
It's a win for the Yanks, and hopefully they take advantage of the transactions to follow in the coming weeks.
