At one point in time, New York Yankees hurler Clarke Schmidt was the kind of talented, young, and controllable pitcher that teams dreamed of. Set to turn 31 in January, Schmidt is no longer young, and now, in his final year of arbitration, he is no longer controllable. The talent part? Well, we think it's still there, but injuries have made it hard to tell recently.
There's some thought that Schmidt could be trade bait, and while that might usually be the case, this winter presents an unusual challenge. Schmidt's value clearly isn't what it once was, but generally speaking, everyone needs pitching, and a cheap arm has value. However, as MLB insider Jon Morosi reported, teams are wary of trading prospect capital for one-year rentals due to the threat of a lockout bleeding into the 2027 season.
Instead, Morosi posits that teams would be willing to do rental-for-rental trades. That's particularly bad news for New York's chances to move Schmidt. In a normal offseason, the best they'd be able to do is a lottery-ticket type of prospect or two. Those don't sound like much, but just look at how Wilberson De Pena has blossomed after being acquired for Oswald Peraza. With a teen prospect, anything is possible.
But if it's a big-leaguer-for-big-leaguer swap, the best the Yankees could hope to do is take a position player with similar control and injury question marks from another team's roster excess in exchange. It hardly seems worth their time.
New York could simply non-tender Schmidt if the club believes that it could use the roster spot for something of greater value, but that's no guarantee. Fellow righty Luis Gil is a better non-tender candidate, given the fact that he's been awful when healthy and Schmidt has been solid. But, surprisingly, Gil has more trade value in large part because he has three years of team control remaining.
Yankees could try to turn Clarke Schmidt into the next Paul Blackburn, but it could be a dangerous road
If the Yankees decide to keep Schmidt, they are stuck with him. He has no minor league options remaining, so he can't be stashed in Scranton for a rainy day. The rotation is as full as it can be, so barring a catastrophe, the 2017 first-round pick has no role there.
What the Yankees could do is try to turn Schmidt into their next great reliever success story. They've taken failed starters like Luke Weaver, Brent Headrick, and Paul Blackburn into superb bullpen weapons, and perhaps the lighter workload associated with pitching out of the 'pen could help keep him healthy while maximizing his talent at the same time.
That's an intriguing option for a team that desperately needs bullpen depth, and it's probably the best use of an asset, given the market realities. However, it sets up a dangerous situation where Brian Cashman could convince himself that Schmidt is enough of a bullpen upgrade to stop pursuing additions, aside from bringing back David Bednar.
There's a chance that Blackburn prices himself out of what New York is willing to pay, which should be a sign that the Yankees need to look elsewhere for either a more cost-effective upgrade or a more proven option if they're going to pay top dollar. Schmidt shouldn't factor into that equation. Instead, slotting him lower in the bullpen pecking order makes sense. However, knowing the Yankees, he'll be used as an excuse to forgo upgrades, setting the scene for another season with an underpowered bullpen.
