There had been some trade buzz earlier this offseason regarding Luis Gil, but ultimately, the New York Yankees decided that rather than hold out hope that they could find a partner, they'd be better off cutting ties with Gil at the non-tender deadline.
While the 2024 AL Rookie of the Year still had three years of team control remaining, the Yankees decided that his lack of options and his occupation of a 40-man roster spot were too restrictive to wait on a deal and risk the chance to jettison him with no financial ramifications.
The counterpoint to that logic is that by holding him and looking for a trade partner, New York could have dictated his next landing spot. While we've seen a lot of negatives, from the injuries to the command issues to his fastball's decline in both velocity and effectiveness, there are still teams that are starved for pitching and would've been intrigued to take a flier on Gil as a reclamation project.
Ideal places he could've been traded to include the Cincinnati Reds and the Texas Rangers, but while we can look at these (and other) teams as a potential fit, it doesn't mean that they'd have been willing to give up assets in order to acquire him (especially since, without options, he couldn't be sent to the minors to work on his craft). Now that he's on the open market, we could see him land with a nemesis and potentially regain his form and exact revenge on the Yankees.
Four worst-case scenario landing spots where Luis Gil can come back and torment the Yankees
The Boston Red Sox
The Boston Red Sox have been more than willing to acquire Yankees pitchers who have fallen out of favor in the Bronx. Garrett Whitlock and Greg Weissert are two of the most recent and biggest success stories in the New York-to-Boston pipeline.
The Red Sox could try their hand at transforming Gil into an impact reliever a la Whitlock, but they also really need a right-handed arm in their extremely lefty-heavy rotation. Gil's best outing of 2026 came in Boston back on April 21, when he threw 6 1/3 innings of shutout ball. That momentum didn't stick with the Yankees, but that might have impressed the Sox enough to give him a shot. If he returns to form, he could haunt the Yankees for years to come.
The Houston Astros
Perhaps no team in the league needs starting pitching reinforcements more than the Houston Astros. They have Hunter Brown, who dealt with injuries and took half a step back following 2025's third-place finish in the AL Cy Young voting. Then there's Peter Lambert, who arrived in Houston as a minor league free agent and punched above his weight class. Still, Lambert went from posting a 3.14 ERA in the first half of 2026 to running out of gas and recording a 4.65 ERA in the second half.
Houston doesn't have a lot of wiggle room in their budget, thanks to bloated contracts given to Christian Walker, Jose Altuve, Carlos Correa, and others. They likely can't aim much higher than the Gil tier to fill their fifth starter spot.
Once upon a time, the Astros were highly interested in Gil while they were shopping Kyle Tucker ahead of the 2025 season. Now there's a new regime in place, as former general manager Dana Brown was fired following this year's trade deadline, but there still could be people within the organization who like the right-hander. He could be a bit more than just a low-cost dice roll for them.
The Tampa Bay Rays
There are two things that we know about the Tampa Bay Rays. One, they have faith that they can turn any pitcher around (see: Peralta, Freddy - 2026). They also don't shy away from injury-prone hurlers, as evidenced by how they've stuck by Drew Rasmussen over the years.
Rasmussen is a key reason why Tampa might have interest in Gil. They picked up his $20 million option, with eyes on trading him. If that happens, they'll need a cheap replacement.
The Baltimore Orioles
Another pitching-needy team is the Baltimore Orioles, who are looking to rebound and get back to the postseason after two playoffless years. They also have rotation needs, though the biggest issue for Baltimore is finding a true staff ace.
Gil won't fit that bill, but that might not matter. Orioles president of baseball operations Mike Elias has ignored the need atop the rotation since Corbin Burnes walked out the door, and has typically favored a quantity-over-quality approach when it comes to starters in recent years. He might strike on Gil, hoping to catch lightning in a bottle.
