The rumors that the New York Yankees are eyeing Alec Bohm to shore up their need at third base are confusing. He's a player who has his merits, but overall, he also seems like an underwhelming solution to the current Ryan McMahon problem.
The case for signing the 30-year-old is as follows. Despite his .249 average in 2026, Bohm has some contact skills. He owns a career .273 batting average and has hit .280 or better in three of his six full big league seasons. He struck out at just a 14% rate this year, and a 17% clip for his career. On top of that, he hits lefties pretty well, with an .816 OPS against southpaws in 2026 and a career mark of .853 when he has the platoon advantage.
So, Bohm adds right-handed balance and, in a somewhat muted way, brings the contact prowess that some Luis Arraez stans crave. Unfortunately, his negatives outweigh his positives.
First, contact is the only truly above-average part of his game. He walks at a below-average clip, with his 7.6% walk rate in 2026 serving as his career high. To that end, while he's hit .273 for his career, his on-base percentage is a pedestrian .325. The same holds true for his power. Bohm has hit 20 homers just once, and his .410 career slugging percentage is just average. All in all, he has a career wRC+ of 100, which is exactly league average.
A league-average bat is nothing to sneeze at, but the defensive metrics on Bohm are horrifying. He put up -10 defensive runs saved and -8 outs above average at the hot corner in 2026, and was moved to first base at times to try to hide his glove. An average hitter and poor defender is a below-average overall player, and he's essentially McMahon, but in reverse.
If the price was right, you still might be able to stomach all of that, but in addition to an uncharacteristically low .249 average, he also recorded a .315 OBP and .383 SLG, which represent the worst performances of his career since 2021. Now you're looking at a below-average hitter with a porous glove who is looking for a bounce back. Not ideal.
The third base market is very thin, but if we're looking at bounce-back candidates, there are a handful of better options that New York can target.
3 higher upside candidates the Yankees should target over Alec Bohm
Eugenio Suarez
If we're talking about guys who could bounce back in 2027, Eugenio Suarez would certainly be a cheaper option. He's also one with greater upside. Suarez will be 36 next July, meaning that he's only looking at a one-year deal. After the Reds declined his $16 million mutual option, he's looking to make about half that, tops. Compared to the two years and $30 million that Jim Bowden predicted for Bohm, that's quite the value.
Suarez has warts. He's not a good defender either. He strikes out a lot, which some fans will hate. But he has elite power, even at his advanced age. The well-traveled slugger missed time with a strained oblique, but even though he played just 125 games, he still hit 26 homers. He really heated up down the stretch, hitting .235/.363/.523 with 12 dingers from Aug. 1 onward.
The fact that both the Reds and Mariners brought him back for second tours of duty says something, too. Geno is one of the most well-liked players in the game and a great clubhouse presence. The bottom line: at his peak, he's been wildly more productive than Bohm, and the final two months of this past season had him looking like he did in his prime years.
Jordan Westburg
Intradivision trades are hard, but the Yankees match up well with the Orioles here. Baltimore's president of baseball operations, Mike Elias, has stated that he'll listen to offers for anyone not named Pete Alonso as he seeks upgrades in the starting rotation and outfield. Speaking of Alonso, the 2026 Silver Slugger nominee has a stranglehold on the cold corner for the O's. That's created an incredible logjam on third base.
Baltimore has Coby Mayo, Christian Encarnacion-Strand, Jordan Westburg, and Blaze Alexander all capable of handling the hot corner. Of the quartet, the Orioles likely value the versatile Alexander the most. The Yankees' best option would be a play for Westburg, as both Mayo and Encarnacion-Strand need to prove that their 2026 breakouts weren't flukes.
Westburg has been a consistent performer when he's able to take the field. The 2024 All-Star owns a career .264/.312/.456 line, but missed the entirety of 2026 after undergoing Tommy John surgery. He's also never played more than 107 games in a single season. That will make him both relatively cheap to acquire and a risk moving forward.
The good news is that all of his ailments have been fluke things rather than chronic issues. Westburgh can play a decent third base, but also has the ability to slide to second, opening up more potential avenues for New York to improve the roster.
Corey Seager
Neither Bohm nor Suarez nor Westburg has the upside that Corey Seager possesses. The two-time World Series MVP is coming off the worst season of his career, hitting .227/.312/.424 with 20 homers. He's also owed $157.5 million over the next five years. There are some things to consider before you cross him off the list.
Seager dealt with back issues that sent him to the IL twice last season, but when he returned to the lineup for the final time on July 31, he looked like his old self, slashing .269/.332/.472. That includes a brutal final week of the season that brought down those numbers a bit. The point is, the back issues clearly affected him, and once he was healthy he slugged the same way he has throughout his whole career.
No doubt his durability is a question, and it's pretty problematic given his contract. With that said, he's a beast in the playoffs and still has superstar upside. He might not cost much to acquire either. Rangers insider Evan Grant posited that a package of Giancarlo Stanton, Anthony Volpe, and Ryan Weathers could get the job done. That doesn't seem like too high a price given the level of talent Seager still possesses.
