3 Yankees nightmare scenarios after MLB lockout ends

OAKLAND, CALIFORNIA - SEPTEMBER 25: Matt Olson #28 of the Oakland Athletics looks on between innings against the Houston Astros at RingCentral Coliseum on September 25, 2021 in Oakland, California. (Photo by Lachlan Cunningham/Getty Images)
OAKLAND, CALIFORNIA - SEPTEMBER 25: Matt Olson #28 of the Oakland Athletics looks on between innings against the Houston Astros at RingCentral Coliseum on September 25, 2021 in Oakland, California. (Photo by Lachlan Cunningham/Getty Images)
3 of 3
Next
Matt Olson #28 of the Oakland Athletics (Photo by Tim Warner/Getty Images)
Matt Olson #28 of the Oakland Athletics (Photo by Tim Warner/Getty Images) /

So, you’re trying to build a contender, are you, New York Yankees? Well, then, you might’ve wanted to start doing so prior to MLB’s sure-to-be-endless lockout, which officially began last week and put a freeze on every pending transaction.

Yes, even Justin Verlander to the Astros.

Though the Yanks didn’t put pen to paper with anyone except Joely Rodriguez prior to the lockout — in retrospect, pretty dumb! — they’re theoretically prepared to play around in the sandbox and rejoin the frenzy when everything’s settled in the spring and many top free agents have only a few weeks to find a new home.

The problem? Every other team, including most of the big spenders (Red Sox, Dodgers, Astros) will be in the exact same boat.

What, the Yankees thought they’d just be able to waltz into the end of the offseason and clean up like Supermarket Sweep? Get real. Everybody wants in on this. Hal Steinbrenner will still have to fork over some fairly big bucks.

Even based solely on the rumors that have leaked out in the early days of the lockout, there are plenty of ways this could all still go haywire for the Bombers, even if Brian Cashman is given full permission to splash cash. Plenty of the team’s rivals want in on the same players they’re pursuing. The superstar trade option who was supposedly at the “one-yard line” of joining the Yankees several weeks ago now is coveted by a series of major players.

Oh, and the ever-annoying Boston Red Sox seem prepared to at least consider throwing their current infield alignment in a trash can just to make our lives hell.

Out of all the things that could go wrong (namely, sitting on our hands and opting out of participating), these three nightmares seem most likely to occur.

3 Yankees nightmares that could happen when MLB lockout ends.

3. Matt Olson to the Rangers

Yeah, having an “Oops, All Rangers!” offseason would be a pretty big bummer.

The Yankees have already lost out on not one, but two of the iconic free agent shortstops on the market to these very same Rangers, a team that got lapped in the AL West last season and seemed to basically surrender midway through the campaign. That’s the team that’s gonna grab Marcus Semien and Corey Seager from you, and still have enough foresight left over to swing a deal for Matt Olson from within the division’s walls while the Yankees sit tight and treat Anthony Rizzo like Manny Diaz in Miami?

“Hey, Anthony! Our No. 1 guy, something we’ve always said! How’ve you been, man!”

If the Yankees want to, they can absolutely outbid the Rangers for Olson, if it comes down to it. Texas’ entire future hinges on Josh Jung and Jack Leiter, their top two prospects and crown jewels. Outside of those two names, most of their farm system consists of recently-traded Yanks from the Joey Gallo deal. As long as New York is willing to include Oswald Peraza and 1-2 of their high-ceiling pitchers, they can do better.

This scenario will likely unfold if (and when) Freddie Freeman heads back to the Atlanta Braves. That’ll make New York and Texas the Olson finalists, left to duel with each other. If Freeman leaves Atlanta, the Braves will hop in the mix … but the Yankees can also just go ahead and sign the ex-MVP! Freeman and Olson both being off the table, thanks to the intrusions of an AL West bottom-feeder yet again would be a certified disaster.

Seiya Suzuki #51 of Team Japan (Photo by Koji Watanabe/Getty Images)
Seiya Suzuki #51 of Team Japan (Photo by Koji Watanabe/Getty Images) /

2. Losing Seiya Suzuki to Red Sox Because of a Fake Budget

Here we go again …

Japanese phenom Seiya Suzuki has officially been posted to MLB, but can’t be signed — like everyone else — until the lockout ends. For some heretofore unknown reason, though, Suzuki rumors leaked this week, and it seems like a trio of AL East teams are hot on his heels: the Yankees, Red Sox and Blue Jays.

Brian Cashman, dressed like an elf and fighting the Grinch, was unable to comment. We’ll take the report’s word for it.

According to rumblings out of Boston, Chaim Bloom has made it known that he’s very interested in chasing the patient and powerful LF/CF/RF, especially after he cleared room by sending Hunter Renfroe to Milwaukee at the horn, just before the bars shuttered on the league’s windows.

Most thought, at the time, that the maneuver would make Boston major players for Kyle Schwarber, who was unable to complete a rumored Phillies deal ahead of the deadline, too. It seems more likely now that Bloom was reshuffling the deck chairs with Suzuki in mind, meaning the Yankees really need to hustle to get their ducks in a row here.

After all, the potential right-handed Hideki Matsui clone — who can also spell Aaron Hicks in center — had been rumored to get a $7-10 million AAV deal. How high can that really climb? $11 or 12 million for four years? If the Yankees let Suzuki walk to the Red Sox just because of a salary cap they’ve invented, while failing to address their clear outfield depth issues, that would be a miscalculation.

And one we’ve seen too many times before.

Houston Astros shortstop Carlos Correa; Mandatory Credit: Troy Taormina-USA TODAY Sports
Houston Astros shortstop Carlos Correa; Mandatory Credit: Troy Taormina-USA TODAY Sports /

1. Red Sox Blowing Up Shortstop Market for Correa or Story

The Red Sox wouldn’t really pivot Xander Bogaerts to second base in his theoretical walk year (player opt-out after 2022) just so they could pay Carlos Correa $350 million … would they?

What about if the position switch allowed them to pay Trevor Story about half that? What, then?

On the surface, it wouldn’t make much sense for Boston to be in the shortstop market, and the idea of them heavily pursuing Javier Baez at second made a lot more sense before that Detroit deal was consummated. Even so … they’re certainly poking around. The Sox are one of five known teams to have checked in on Correa before the lockout, joining the Yankees in that fray, and they’ve been rumored to be exploring Story for many different holes on the diamond, from short to second to center.

There’s no other way to put this: the only thing more embarrassing for the Yankees than not signing an expensive shortstop this offseason would be watching the Red Sox do it without a real need.

Imagine the gall of that? “Oh, yeah, a shortstop? Sure. We can do $300 million. We’ll just move our MVP candidate to second, then maybe let him walk and replace him with a tippy-top prospect. We’ll just grab your talent and ask questions later, thanks.”

It’s wild, but it’s also what good organizations do, teams that want to win both now and later and don’t use their luxury tax as a hard cap. This would be Boston’s most powerful punking of the modern Yankees to date. There is no excuse to be silent while Bloom is loud, especially here … and yet, it’s very possible.

Next