Yankees' year-over-year comeback win shift flies in face of fanbase's pessimism

You know 'em. You love 'em. They're the Yankees fans that love to tweet, when some opponent hits a two-run home run in the second inning, "Classic Boone Yankees. This one's over." And while Yanks Go Yard may be the internet's foremost home of "Classic Boone Yankees" discourse — when they fade in the summer, when they get sloppy on the bases, when someone's playing out of position and gets defended for their malfeasance, we'll be there! — this particular accusation has been refuted time and again this year.

Not only are the 2026 Yankees a solid comeback team, but they're actually one of baseball's very best.

Sometimes, those comebacks are team efforts, where the stadium shakes and each member of the offense becomes undeniable in rapid succession. Sometimes, they're individual comeback stories — like Trent Grisham, who was cursed out by Will Warren on Wednesday for his shoddy defense, then went on to mash a home run to cut the deficit to one, smoke a double that untied the game, and reach the bullpen one more time for good measure.

No matter how you slice it, the Yankees now have 25 wins when trailing in the seventh inning or later, third-best in baseball and three more than they had in the entire 162-gamer last year.

Yankees' comeback streak by the numbers proves they're among MLB's best

Katie Sharp also noted that Wednesday was the Yankees' 31st comeback win of any kind this year, tied with the stupid Rays (go away!) for best in baseball.

This all goes back to the larger point: the Yankees' admirable work this summer, while undermanned and facing top-tier competition, has gotten lost in the shuffle for multiple reasons. Some fans simply don't want to hear about it; after all, losing Aaron Judge is worse luck and a worse outcome than any individual game can be "good". We get that. Others got so angry about the 1-9 stretch that ended against the Twins that they sort of forgot to plug back in (or can't acknowledge the good helping to balance out the bad because the bad was so bad). Still others cannot believe how tightly they grip the bat in extra innings, impugning their work in all close games because of it — and it is insane how they're 2-9 in those scenarios. That is the true Boone Ball. They'd have even more comeback wins if they could hack it with the Ghost Runner — ninth-inning rally vs. Aroldis Chapman, Grisham's game-tying smash vs. the Braves on Sunday, etc.

Some relied on the trade deadline to reinvigorate their enthusiam, and then Brian Cashman forgot to get a catcher and subtracted bullpen pieces. That wasn't good. I was certainly in that boat.

Mostly, it feels like the Yankees' season was completely swallowed up by the Red Sox season for six weeks. When your chief rival goes 32-5, they're bound to overwhelm any team, whether that team is collapsing or surviving.

Now that the Sox have started to at least play normally for a bit, maybe fans will acknowledge that, with George Lombard Jr. in place and Spencer Jones hitting his stride and the stadium breathing electricity on Wednesday night, there is something to enjoy here.

The Yankees are alive, whether you can feel them breathing or not. And while a multi-run deficit felt like a death sentence at the offense's lowest point, the Yankees, on the whole, have been better than most at digging out of them.

Some fans won't believe it 'til October, and we don't blame them. But all the data we have for now indicates they have a degree of The Juice.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow