Yankees-Pirates David Bednar trade is evening out amid Rafael Flores Jr. breakout

When the New York Yankees looked to shore up their bullpen last season, GM Brian Cashman knew that it wouldn’t come cheaply. The Yankees were ready to part ways with talented prospects if it meant a better chance at improving the ball club, and it has mostly paid off. After they made a deal with the Pittsburgh Pirates for pitcher David Bednar, some critics actually thought that the Yankees got away with highway robbery. But as it turns out, that trade was a win-win for both sides. And that's mainly because of Rafael Flores Jr. 

Despite missing out on the playoffs in 2026, the Pittsburgh Pirates have had one of their best seasons in years. They even have an opportunity to finish over the .500 mark for the first time since the 2018 season. That success has largely been fueled by offensive breakout seasons from players like Flores Jr.

The young catcher has put the league on notice with an impressive stretch to close out the season. After hitting just four home runs in 65 games for Triple-A Indianapolis, Flores Jr. has gone on an absolute tear for the Pirates. In 43 games in the big leagues, he's launched 10 bombs and driven in 22 runs. His .910 OPS for the Buccos is also more than 200 points higher than his season mark in the minors.  

For a Yankees club that has been severely lacking offensive production from the catcher position, it certainly stings to see yet another former player catch fire for another team. Similar to the season that Carlos Narváez had for the Boston Red Sox in 2024, Flores Jr. may be giving the Yankees a bit of seller's remorse. We will have to wait and see if Flores Jr. will be able to keep up his hot bat next season, but as of now, it appears that the Bednar trade has become about as even as it gets. 

The Yankees needed David Bednar at any cost

Seeing Flores Jr. flourish in Pittsburgh is like seeing an ex become a millionaire overnight. You can't help but feel a little jealous at the type of season he's had while Austin Wells and Ali Sánchez struggle to supply any production at the plate. In a third of the games played, Flores Jr. has all but matched the fWAR of both Wells and Sánchez combined in 2026. The former highly-rated Yankees prospect is swiftly matching the hype.    

Regardless of the price that they paid, Bednar has been an amazing pickup for the Yankees. In a season and a half, he’s collected 44 saves and his presence has really helped to stabilize the back end of the bullpen. His ability to routinely collect more than three outs in any game adds a level of versatility that eludes even some of the most elite closers.    

In his 83 appearances for the Yankees over the last two seasons, Bednar boasts an ERA+ of 170 and a very respectable 1.011 WHIP. While he can sometimes flirt with danger and make ball games interesting, he has been as close to a sure thing to pick up a save as the Yankees have had in years. 

Although his 1.9 fWAR doesn’t quite rank him among some of the 10 best relievers in baseball, the value he has brought to the Yankees is unmistakable. That means that he was worth the price that the Yankees paid to acquire him, even if the trade appears en route to becoming more balanced over time.

Good pitching will always be key for any team to win a championship. Preventing the other team from putting up crooked numbers is one of the most effective ways to come out on top at the end of a game. But it can be difficult to find and develop the level of pitching needed to achieve that. This can be especially true when it comes to late-inning relievers. That means a premium is usually paid.    

We’ve seen the Yankees win and lose trades over the years. It's all part of the risk you take when you build a win-now team. Some of those trades hit, some don't. The Yankees needed a pitcher like Bednar to help them in the postseason so they pulled the trigger. And while trading Flores Jr. for that reason could benefit the Pirates more in the long run, a World Series title in 2026 would erase any feeling of regret for the Yankees. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow