Skip to main content

Yankees just got a cheap Carson Kelly alternative at catcher that has fans fearing the worst

Hey, no. Don't. Go bigger.
ByAdam Weinrib
Atlanta Braves v. New York Mets
Atlanta Braves v. New York Mets | Michael Urakami/GettyImages

Joey Bart, a "coveted" trade deadline chip in a weak catching market last winter, would represent a higher degree of intentionality than Ali Sanchez did last summer for the Yankees. He'd be an actual, viable backup catcher, but he'd be very unlikely to be more than that.

Unfortunately, he's more aligned with the Yankees' budget and devotion to Austin Wells as the de facto starter than alternative options like Carson Kelly and Ryan Jeffers, who decided to take the qualifying offer on Tuesday rather than explore anything.

The second Bart was designated for assignment to clear roster space ahead of the Rule 5 protection deadline, he became the most obvious Yankees fit on the catching market. Now, you've got fans on both sides of the aisle, trying to crunch all the permutations where it could possibly work, but also dreading the reality that the Yankees' bar just got lower.

Can Joey Bart actually provide hope for Yankees after White Sox DFA?

We didn't get much data on post-deadline Bart in Chicago. There's a reason the cover photo still has him in a Braves uniform. He broke his hand on a HBP at Fenway Park, ending his season hitting .214 in 112 at-bats.

He's a former top draft pick with the San Francisco Giants, but that label feels completely unearned at this point. In reality, he's a sturdy backup, potentially not even on a first-division team. He doesn't mash any handedness any better than the other. He's a career .237 hitter with a .319 OBP against righties, and a .237 hitter with a .318 OBP against lefties. It's shockingly identical behavior from a man whose upside lies in the Baseball America prospect handbook from a half-decade ago more than it lies on the field.

Bringing Bart in wouldn't be a disappointment, per se, but the Yankees finding a way to convince Kelly to come aboard at less than $10 million per year would be much more exciting. He'd be taking on more of a half-share of the catching duties with Wells, as opposed to Bart, who'd be a pure once-a-week backup. Can the Yankees convince Kelly to come aboard at that level of responsibility. Will ownership approve the expenditure for a half-starter? Will they shoot for upside, or be happy with sturdiness? Now you see why we fear they'll take the easy way out in Bart before the conversation even really gets a chance to begin.

Add us as a preferred source on Google