Yankees insider's trade deadline solutions for catcher aren't as simple as they seem

On the surface, the New York Yankees' trade deadline needs are obvious. For the fifth year in a row, they need to address the bullpen. They also have a problem behind the plate with two lefty catchers, neither of whom produce offensively.

Ever since the offseason, fans have been zoning in on one of the most obvious trade fits in Ryan Jeffers of the Minnesota Twins. And most recently, Yankees insider Joel Sherman made the connection on an episode of the Pinstripe Post.

Jeffers is admittedly a great fit. He's a slugging righty catcher who can absorb starting reps. His defense is good. This year, he registered 1.8 WAR in just 37 games before suffering an unfortunate injury.

And that's one of the issues. Though Jeffers' power has been up-and-down throughout his career, a hamate bone injury is sure to threaten the longevity of that aspect of his game for the remainder of the 2026 campaign.

Not only that, but Jeffers is an impending free agent on a Twins team that is probably going to sell at the trade deadline. That means there will be plenty of competition here, and Brian Cashman's least favorite thing is getting in a bidding war for a rental. There are always exceptions, but this wouldn't be one.

Yankees will need to get creative with catcher pursuit at trade deadline

We're not writing off Jeffers by any means. He's just the most obvious fit and those are the typical candidates Cashman and the front office avoid. Jeffers also only got his stitches removed from the surgery he underwent a few days ago, so there's still a significant recovery ahead.

Next up: division rival Adley Rutschman. That would constitute a blockbuster trade of sorts. And again, it's something the Yankees (and Orioles!) probably wouldn't even entertain.

An in-division trade involving a former All-Star would require a Yankees Tax no fan would be able to stomach. That means Cashman won't be touching it with a 10-foot pole. The switch-hitting Rutschman is better from the right side of the plate, too, and the Orioles will know to take advantage of the Yankees' needs.

If the Yankees are able to pull off either trade, it'll be considered a major acquisition. Jeffers would be a costly perfect fit for two months. Rutschman would signal the end of Austin Wells in pinstripes as the Orioles slugger is controllable through 2027.

But we might have to get a bit more creative here. Maybe Ivan Herrera of the Cardinals? We think a "dream big" candidate might be Salvador Perez, as the Royals continue to descend into the abyss and might need an infusion of more young talent. Both of those seem more likely than the above options, but we'll just have to wait and see how the standings/market shake out over the next two months.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow