Yankees’ Heliot Ramos trade somehow looks layers more disastrous after ALDS Game 2

It would be perfectly understandable if that headline made you double check the box score to see if you somehow missed Heliot Ramos taking the field in the New York Yankees’ tough Game 2 loss to the Tampa Bay Rays. But it's the fact that the Yankees struggle to find any real use for Ramos that makes his trade a real disaster and a complete waste of a roster spot.  

The Rays trotted out two lefty relievers in Game 2 in an attempt to neutralize the Yankees’ onslaught of left-handed bats. Cam Booser came in for Rays’ starting pitcher Freddy Peralta and he walked one heck of a tightrope to narrowly escape a fifth inning jam. After facing just two batters and recording only one out, Rays manager Kevin Cash decided to bring in LHP Ian Seymour to bridge the gap to closer Bryan Baker in the ninth.  

Despite giving up a solo shot to Ben Rice in the eighth inning, Seymour tossed three spectacular innings and made sure he never gave the Yankees any hope of mounting a comeback. With the lineup filled with eight left-handed batters, the Yankees seemed to play right into Cash’s master plan. 

You might assume that a player like Ramos would make for the perfect option to bring into the game in place of one of those lefty hitters. If you recall back at the trade deadline, Yankees GM Brian Cashman acquired Ramos for the exact purpose of becoming another one of the team’s weapons to combat left-handed pitching.

As Ryan Garcia of Just Baseball pointed out, the Yankees traded prospects Kaeden Kent and Henry Lalane to the San Francisco Giants to add Ramos to their roster. The Yankees thought highly enough of him to surrender Lalane, a top-five prospect in their system, in hopes he would provide some much-needed pop against lefties.  

But with Paul Goldschmidt hitting for Ryan McMahon in the top of the eighth inning, he became the Yankees only pinch hitter of the game. Even as Luis García Jr. and Spencer Jones struck out in their at-bats against Seymour, Ramos never left the comfort of his own spot on the bench. If he couldn’t even be brought out for an at-bat against the Rays’ southpaws, why is he even on the ALDS roster for the Yankees? 

Heliot Ramos never seemed like a good fit for the Yankees 

With a .297/.383/.525 slash line against LHP in 2026, Ramos can rake. We can’t pretend that he isn’t a quality player for that skillset. He even had a brief redemption arc that made fans briefly think that the Yankees won the trade. But with a .651 OPS in 303 at-bats against right-handed pitchers this season, Ramos has gradually limited himself at the plate. His strength against LHP still makes him a very strong platoon player to have on a Major League roster. Just not the Yankees’ roster. 

As a poor defender, Ramos is tough to justify penciling in the lineup as an outfielder. That means that he is best suited to fill in as a DH. But with Rice now almost exclusively serving as the Yankees’ full-time DH, Ramos will never steal at-bats away from the Yankees' best offensive player in 2026. 

At the same time, Ramos’ lack of defensive prowess makes him a liability to have out there in the field with a team already famous for giving their opponent extra outs to play with. That leaves his only option as a pinch hitter against LHP. Even then, Yankees manager Aaron Boone couldn’t see the value in taking the bat out of the hands of anyone else in the lineup in Game 2.  

That all but puts the final nail in the coffin for Ramos’ career with the Yankees. For a rebuilding team looking to add a solid hitter, he can provide solid value at the plate. For a playoff contending team looking for a platoon player to face off against LHP as their DH, Ramos can again provide solid value. But the Yankees have neither of those needs. And their Game 2 loss against the Rays’ lefties made that obvious.  

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow