Yankees fans can't overlook unfortunate Brent Headrick reality as hot run continues

One of our "pretend" concerns actually came true in the first four weeks of the New York Yankees' 2026 season. That's not a reflection of our pessimism, though. We didn't think the bullpen would be this bad.

But we are officially worried about Brent Headrick's workload for the remainder of the campaign. The left-hander has been extremely effective for the Bombers, logging a 1.50 ERA, 2.05 FIP and 14 strikeouts in 12 innings.

We must say, his 1.50 WHIP (because of his trouble with walks, as evidenced by lefties having a .500 OBP against him) as well as his defense (two errors) are a bit of a problem. But nobody expected him to be this good, lead the league in games played (14), and lead the Yankees in innings pitched after just 22 games. All of a sudden, he's become incredibly important.

While it's an encouraging development, it also raises questions for further down the road. Headrick logged 23 innings at the MLB level last year, with his career-high coming back in 2023 (25 2/3 with the Minnesota Twins).

For his career (split between the minors and majors), Headrick topped out at 108 1/3 back in 2022 (when he was coming up as a starter). His next highest total is 100 2/3 innings, which he achieved in 2023. But since then he's been limited to only 22 1/3 and 47 the last two years.

How can Yankees handle Brent Headrick's workload for the rest of the 2026 season?

Let's be fair and meet in the middle. Let's say Headrick is reasonably good for 50 innings this year. Remember, he's being used a good amount in high-leverage, so that's going to affect his stamina in the long run. Are we sure this isn't going to be detrimental to his availability in Aug./Sept.? Will he even be part of the picture by then?

For example, Fernando Cruz saw 48 innings across 49 games last year. He dealt with some injuries, but he was used very similarly in the early going by Aaron Boone (16 2/3 innings in April/March).

By September, Cruz was cooked. He logged a 6.75 ERA and 1.97 WHIP in his final 10 2/3 innings. And that was somebody with an extensive MLB track record over his previous two seasons with the Cincinnati Reds (132 2/3 innings). Headrick doesn't have the experience or the longevity on his side.

Perhaps the Yankees have a plan, whether it be promoting guys from Triple-A or making multiple trade deadline splashes for relievers. Maybe there are a couple phantom IL stints for Headrick. We'll try and stay positive because we really enjoy watching him, but it's hard to envision this getting all the way to the finish line.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow