Yankees could see added benefits from Orioles-Red Sox Adley Rutschman trade

It would have been nice for the New York Yankees to do something more to fortify the catcher position than sign Mitch Garver, but Brian Cashman couldn't seem to find value that he liked. Therefore, we're stuck looking at silver linings, hoping that Garver can help in certain situations.

The harsh reality is, and this is to make no excuse for Cashman and the club, there wasn't much actually available on the catching market. Ryan Jeffers, Hunter Goodman, and Shea Langeliers were not truly up for grabs, and the best catcher who found himself on the trade block was Adley Rutschman, who, of course, went to the Boston Red Sox.

The price tag on Rutschman was insane, and to an extent, New York was wise to walk away from its pursuit of the switch-hitting backstop. By doing so, the Yankees might have actually aided the Red Sox and Orioles in joining together down a path of mutually assured destruction.

The Yankees might get the last laugh as both the Red Sox and the Orioles could end up losing the Adley Rutschman trade

Boston surrendered three of their top-five prospects, Anthony Eyanson, Kyson Witherspoon, and Enddy Azocar, in order to land Rutschman, which is the type of return you'd expect a superstar to generate.

Rutschman, the first overall pick of the 2019 draft, at one time did look like a burgeoning superstar, with back-to-back 5.5 WAR campaigns to begin his career in 2022 and 2023. However, that was long ago.

Rutschman's bat began to fall off in 2024 when his wRC+ dropped from 134 in 2022 to 126 in 2023 to 103 in 2024. Of course, a 103 wRC+ from a catcher, especially one with Rutschman's defensive skills, is very solid, but the step back was noticeable. It also might have foreshadowed what was to come.

The second half of 2024 saw the 28-year-old slump hard. He posted a .585 OPS over his final 234 plate appearances. That led to a disappointing 2025 campaign that saw him record a .673 OPS. Rutschman got off to a red-hot first month of the season in 2026, but since May 1, he has a .671 OPS over 220 plate appearances.

Injuries have played a role, and Rutschman is currently working his way back from a wrist injury. It's likely that the injuries over the years have sapped his offensive production, and there's a decent shot that this trend will continue.

On a larger scale, this trade could be the nail in the coffin for Boston's vaunted farm system. Over the last few years the Red Sox have spent accumulating assets, there have been many notable misses. Kristian Campbell owns a pedestrian .728 OPS in Triple-A. Marcelo Mayer got shipped to the Giants after failing to show anything at the big league level. Roman Anthony was great last year, but struggled before missing most of 2026 with an injury.

The last wave of star Red Sox prospects hasn't lived up to expectations, and now giving up a good chunk of blue-chippers waiting in the wings for Rutschman is another huge blow. Boston's plan has essentially gone off the rails, and they're not the free agency players they once were.

Now, there are rumblings that Boston is mulling extending Rutschman. Red Sox chief baseball officer Craig Breslow seems all-in on the idea of Rutschman and highlighted the importance of his additional year of team control.

Depending on what the terms of a potential extension would be, the Red Sox might handcuff themselves to a depreciating asset for years to come, which, when combined with a thinned-out farm system, could lead to their downfall.

Now, for the Orioles side of things, the situation is quite simple. After appearing like an up-and-coming force in 2024, Baltimore's struggles last season and this season have shown that the concerns raised last year were valid. Their core isn't as well-rounded as they once thought, and trading away Rutschman could be the sign that they're acknowledging their shortcomings and starting over.

Buster Olney of ESPN told The Just Baseball Show that this is just the beginning and that Gunnar Henderson will be the next Oriole to be dealt. Henderson's a Scott Boras client and is highly unlikely to sign an extension, and without him, their wings will be clipped.

Put it all together, and in the near future, the Yankees could see two of their biggest rivals take major steps back, with the Rutschman trade being the catalyst for it all. That'd be a huge development for New York, as the AL East is typically one of the most competitive divisions in baseball year in and year out. There are still some dominoes to fall, but if things go the way they're trending, the Yankees will be sitting pretty.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow