The Toronto Blue Jays were a major thorn in the New York Yankees' side in 2025, and eventually were the reason why the Yankees went home empty-handed last October. That won't be the case this year, as the Blue Jays have officially been eliminated from playoff contention.
A lot went wrong for Toronto, but the single greatest reason for their failings in 2026 has been Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Vladdy Jr. has posted a .695 OPS so far this season and didn't hit his first home run at the Rogers Centre until September 13. Inflation is real! Half a billion dollars doesn't buy you nearly as much as it used to.
Yankees fans haven't missed their chances to take shots at the Jays, as trade deadline pickup Luis Garcia Jr. has looked much more Guerrero-like than the Toronto thoroughbred and has done so while making about a fifth of the money this season. In response to the campaign, Guerrero, in an interview with Veronica Batista of Noticias Telemicro in the Dominican Republic, came out with one of the lamest defenses of a down year following a big contract that you'll ever see.
"I want people to understand one thing. The money they gave me wasn’t for what I’m going to do. It was for what I already did. They didn’t pay me because I’m going to hit 40 every year. They paid me for what I already accomplished. People are confused about that, but I think the same way they do. Like, sometimes I even say to myself: bro, they gave you all that money and you’re out here doing nothing. I try," Guerrero said in Spanish, as translated by Phillip Feliz, also known as @Masterflip_ on Twitter/X.
What? They gave you a 14-year, $500 million contract to compensate you for what you did over the first six years of your career, and with no expectation that you'll produce for the next decade and a half? That's a new one.
Was it a bad translation? (It wasn't.) Did Guerrero Jr. simply not communicate his thoughts well? Was something taken out of context? Nope. When asked to clarify his comments, he doubled down.
When Vladimir Guerrero Jr. was asked if he regrets his comments (by @MitchBannon):
— Keegan Matheson (@KeeganMatheson) September 23, 2026
"No, I don't regret myself. I'm not lying with what I say. I understand some fans, they don't understant the way and what I was trying to say specifically, but what I said is the way I feel."
"No, I don't regret myself. I'm not lying with what I say. I understand some fans, they don't understand the way and what I was trying to say specifically, but what I said is the way I feel," Guerrero Jr. said when beat reporters asked follow-up questions.
The Yankees won't have to worry about the Blue Jays for a while if this is truly Vladimir Guerrero Jr.'s attitude
Since it seems that Vladdy doesn't understand how business works in the MLB, it was his performance while under team control that led the Jays to feel comfortable handing him such a lavish sum, with the expectation that he'd continue at a similar rate, or even improve.
At 27 years old, he's just entering his prime. He could've made the point that a contract like the massive 14-year pact he was given means that the team understands that the last few years of the deal will be underwater as age-related decline sets in. But we should be talking about his age-37 season being the drop-off, not what should've been one of the best years of his career.
Given the labor strife that will come this offseason, he could have made the more meta point that he and many others are vastly underpaid during the first six years of their careers due to the pre-arbitration and arbitration processes. He'd have a valid point, one which might be litigated during CBA negotiations, but it wouldn't be a valid response to the question at hand, which was how he feels about his down year.
Guerrero didn't say any of that. He literally shirked any responsibility to perform. Don't try to emulate this strategy with your boss.
Now, he could be an anchor on Toronto's books for years to come, and it might be a situation they can't survive. The Jays threw around a lot of money this past offseason on players like Dylan Cease, Kazuma Okamoto, Cody Ponce, and others. They're owned by Canadian conglomerate Rogers Communications Inc.
There's no doubt that there are deep-pocketed Canucks in charge, but it's also a large corporation with an eye on profitability above all else. There's a limit to what they will spend, and Guerrero represents a huge portion of their payroll.
We've seen them face similar challenges as the Yankees have this year, with injuries and some poor performances playing a role. With that said, New York clearly emerged as the deeper, more talented, and more successful team. Expect that divergence to continue moving forward.
