Worrisome Aaron Judge problem is boiling beneath the surface for Yankees

Aaron Judge has been struggling recently. Judge is 4-for-27 with zero homers over the last seven games and 11-for-56 (.196) over his last 15 games, with the Yankees going 5-10.

It's not the end of the world for the reigning MVP, who is still slashing .250/.381/.554/.935 on the season with 16 homers; nor is it panic time for the Yankees, who at 30-21 still hold the second-best record in the American League (although a 4.5-game deficit to the AL East-leading Tampa Bay Rays isn't a great development).

But there has been one slightly concerning aspect of Judge's slump: strikeouts. Judge has tallied 22 of them in the last 15 games, and he's currently on pace to fan over 200 times this season, something he hasn't done since his rookie MLB campaign.

On Thursday night against the Toronto Blue Jays, Judge's K in the first inning was his seventh straight strikeout in as many at-bats. Luckily, Judge broke the streak in his next at-bat with a groundout to shortstop.

Should Yankees fans be worried about uncharacteristic Aaron Judge slump?

It's no surprise that the Yankees have been losing a lot during Judge's slump. Despite the illusion that the Yanks have an unstoppable, powerful offense (a narrative born of their MLB-leading 73 home runs), this offense has far less margin for error than most people realize.

The emergence of Ben Rice as an MVP-type bat has been incredible, but that's just one positive in 2026 amid a collection of problems: Jazz Chisholm Jr. stinking (his 60 strikeouts are second on the Yanks behind Judge), Trent Grisham stinking (.174 batting average), another Giancarlo Stanton never-ending injury, and a bottom of the order that's been awful all year (Ryan McMahon and Austin Wells are both sub-Mendoza Line stinkers).

When Chisholm and Grisham are locked in, and when Stanton is available, even New York's ghastly bottom of the order ceases to matter, especially considering the Yankees' stellar rotation that — for the most part — hasn't required a massive amount of run support this season.

But when any team — the Yankees included — sees two or three key bats either head to the IL or underperform dramatically, the pendulum subsequently shifts from good offense to bad, placing immense pressure on the guys who aren't completely drowning at the plate. For the Yankees, this has been Rice, Judge, and Cody Bellinger in 2026.

It's unfair and unrealistic to assume that this trio can carry the entire offense of a contender (that's what the Yankees want to be, right?), and we're seeing this in real time with Judge's individual struggles having a direct impact on the entire Yankees operation.

Impossible standards for Aaron Judge will never go away for Yankees

Every player (superstars included) are allowed and expected to go through slumps. Look at what's been happening with Shohei Ohtani this year. And yet, Judge seems to exist outside of this rule, for whatever reason. From a baseball standpoint, I just outlined above why the Yankees really need Judgey to get it going soon, but on a deeper level, the media and even Yankees manager Aaron Boone seem to act as if Judge isn't supposed to ever go through a cold spell.

Judge powers through it all and continues to produce MVP seasons for the Yankees, and he'll no doubt have a great upcoming series against the Rays. Still, it's worth wondering why we all have to expect Judge to be Superman 24/7. It definitely takes away from appreciating his greatness.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow