What would it take for the Yankees to pull off a blockbuster Bobby Witt Jr. trade?

I woke up in the middle of the night thinking about Yankees shortstops, which probably tells you how my life with limited baseball action is going. Derek Jeter held the prestigious position for two decades, and since he retired in 2014, the Bronx has been searching for his successor. Didi Gregorius did an admirable job from 2015 through 2019, but the Yankees still haven't developed a homegrown franchise shortstop since No. 2 walked off the field for the last time.

Part of that is the shadow Jeter left behind. Five rings, the captaincy and the dynasty of the late '90s is a lot for any young player to live up to, and we've watched that weight land on Anthony Volpe before he was fully ready. George Lombard Jr. has the job now, and Dax Kilby may be up there at some point, but it got me wondering: instead of putting all that pressure on a kid, why not trade for a shortstop who's already a superstar?

Why Bobby Witt Jr. is the perfect Yankees trade target

Bobby Witt Jr. checks every box. He plays a premium position at an elite level and he stole 45 bases this season, exactly the type of speed this lineup is missing. Picture him hitting in front of Aaron Judge, who's under contract through 2031. Pitchers would have to deal with Witt creating chaos on the bases while also figuring out how to navigate the best right-handed hitter on the planet. We saw how dangerous that kind of pairing was with Juan Soto in 2024, and Witt brings the same energy with Gold Glove-caliber defense on top of it.

His contract makes the idea even more tempting. Witt signed an 11-year, $288.8 million extension back in 2024 that pays him $19 million in 2027 and tops out at $35 million a year starting in 2029, with opt-outs after the 2030 season. That's a bargain for a player of his caliber, and it comes with an average annual value of roughly $26 million against the luxury tax. This isn't the Giancarlo Stanton experiment, either. The Yankees absorbed $265 million of Stanton's deal for a slugger whose injuries piled up in pinstripes. Witt is a 26-year-old athlete at a premium position, signed to a team-friendly deal.

Now the hard part. Witt has a full no-trade clause, and he's beloved in Kansas City, where he's embraced being the face of a franchise he wants to win with. The Royals would have to be willing to listen, and Witt would have to sign off. Then there's the new collective bargaining agreement situation this offseason, which could reshape everything if a salary cap enters the picture.

Since we're already living in fantasy land, let's play out what this would take to pull off. The package would have to start with Lombard, and it would probably sting, badly. Volpe might be included as an upside play, and Kansas City would almost certainly demand Kilby, the system's top prospect. Add a big-league-ready arm like Elmer Rodríguez or Carlos Lagrange, or maybe Will Warren or Clarke Schmidt, then sprinkle in a couple of high-ceiling lottery tickets from the lower levels, like Yostin Peña or Wilberson De Peña. Think of that last part as a venture capital play, where the Royals bet that one of them turns into their next billion-dollar company.

So... George Lombard Jr, Anthony Volpe, Will Warren, and Yostin Pena for Bobby Witt Jr.? The Yanks would get at least four years of Bobby's prime with Aaron Judge? Sign me up!

That's a staggering price, I know this, and it would gut the minor league system. But a dynamic, homegrown-feeling star at shortstop, hitting in front of Judge in his prime, could be the move that finally turns the page on the post-Jeter era. This is all completely made up, but if it ever happened and he won a ring in the Bronx, his name would be etched into Yankees history forever.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow