Underrated MLB free agency signings that could impact Yankees

Colorado Rockies v Los Angeles Dodgers
Colorado Rockies v Los Angeles Dodgers / Harry How/GettyImages
2 of 3
Next

The New York Yankees thrived at the top of the free agent market this offseason, but forgot to save enough money to flesh out their roster and fill a few significant lineup holes.

That means expectations should still be sky-ish high for the Bombers (as long as they play the kids), but the team didn't do a fantastic job picking up any underrated signings at the margins. The baseball world might fear Carlos Rodón, but they won't be side-eyeing the Yankees while grumbling, "...Damn, how'd they get that guy for so cheap?"

A few of New York's rivals beefed up more silently this offseason. The Red Sox have been, uh, interesting in free agency, losing Xander Bogaerts, JD Martinez, Nathan Eovaldi and likely Michael Wacha, but at least they've managed to literally fill holes with bodies, making extensive signings (some of whom are guaranteed to be gnats). The Blue Jays would like you to believe they've won the offseason -- and they haven't! -- but they certainly added an impact leader who will give the Yankees fits. While all the energy is on Houston's Jose Abreu signing, they've still maintained their super bullpen in silence.

And, as always, it's impossible to know what the Rays are thinking, but we don't like it. These underrated signings may not all haunt the Yankees, but each addition will stand in New York's way en route to the postseason.

Underrated MLB Free Agency Signings That Will Affect Yankees' 2023 Season

Los Angeles Dodgers  v San Diego Padres
Los Angeles Dodgers v San Diego Padres / Denis Poroy/GettyImages

Justin Turner, Boston Red Sox

Justin Turner has been the leader of the Dodgers so long that he doesn't know what losing feels like. For as strange as Boston's roster looks entering 2023, you just know there's no way they'll completely flatline with Alex Cora at the helm and Turner in the dugout.

Though we'd like to call the 38-year-old "washed up" (and who knows, maybe he goes Full Donaldson this year), he was one of the game's better hitters in the second half in 2022, finishing the season with a 116 OPS+ on the strength of a .319 average and .889 OPS in 44 second-half games. Don't look now, but there's a good chance Turner can replicate JD Martinez's production while being 15-20% scrappier. Boston will enjoy him. It might not be enough, but he and Masataka Yoshida will surely give the Yankees fits and put runners on around Rafael Devers.

Brandon Belt, Toronto Blue Jays

Again, will Brandon Belt lead the Jays to AL East supremacy? We're still waiting for that movie. We've seen the trailer. Kinda looks like "The Fabelmans". Vlad Jr. just loves cinema.

If he doesn't push the Jays over the top, though, he'll at least slug, assuming he's fully healthy, and imbue that locker room with a veteran presence it hasn't had in recent seasons. They're also moving the fences in in Toronto. Never forget that. They cried about the short porch so much they got one of their own.

Belt has long been a plus in the intangibles department, but it doesn't take too much mental gymnastics to envision him repeating his 2021 season, where he hit 29 bombs with a .975 OPS in 97 games.

Of course, 24 of those would come against the Yankees.

Rafael Montero, Houston Astros

Some would call the Astros crazy for extending flame-throwing reliever Rafael Montero for three years. In fact, most would call them crazy for doing it without a GM in place and letting owner Jim Crane freelance his way through the early offseason.

Lord knows, if the Astros had let him go, they would've found some way to replace him and injected another 100 MPH-throwing cyborg into the seventh-inning mix. That said, we'd rather take our chances. Houston should ditch as many known quantities, like Justin Verlander, as possible. Eventually, they'll find a "replacement" who doesn't fit. That's the Yankees' only hope of closing the gap. Maintaining the status quo with Montero will certainly wind up working out -- for at least a season.

Zach Eflin, Tampa Bay Rays

Committing three years to Zach Eflin, a former Phillies starter turned playoff closer, feels like the Rays extended themselves beyond their typical means. If any other team had done this, the baseball world would laugh; Eflin posted a 4.04 ERA in 75.2 innings of his comeback season last year, striking out 65 and relying on the ground ball. He was a strange closer, but somehow, he managed. And somehow managing is the Rays' whole deal.

Eflin's three-year, $40 million commitment represents the largest free agent deal in Tampa Bay Rays history, an utterly insane figure that continues to inspire the Yankees to spend less every year. After all, if the Rays can dominate with the Eflin deal as their ceiling, why can't New York do the same?

Except ... the Rays actually haven't broken through yet. They've made the World Series twice. They've never won it. They're usually a surprisingly easy postseason out, no matter what they've accomplished in the regular season (see: 2021 ALDS against Boston).

That said, if they target a pitcher, they're probably correct to do so. If they pay a somewhat-anonymous pitcher their largest FA contract ever (and outbid the Red Sox to do it), they're probably on the right track. If they extend Jeffery Springs, too, they're ready for battle with a rotation and bullpen of create-a-players.

This shouldn't work, but it presumably will.

Next