5 Yankees most likely to be dealt at the trade deadline

The New York Yankees are in an interesting spot approaching the 2023 MLB trade deadline -- or, at least, interesting to trainwreck enthusiasts.

With Aaron Judge returning and Gerrit Cole dealing, both within their primes, this team technically owes the roster and fan base a few "get right" moves in an effort to sneak into the dance and make some noise. Their Wild Card and AL East deficits are far from insurmountable, even though this fan base knows better by now.

But the 2023 Yankees aren't a Juan Soto away from automatic contention. No matter what they do on Tuesday, they'll need Anthony Rizzo, DJ LeMahieu and Giancarlo Stanton to perform better. That's no secret.

They'll also need to shed some salary to make room for mid-tier imports.

Brian Cashman will need to thread 100 different needles this week to reinvigorate the Yankees, and these five Bombers could find themselves on the outs while the transition occurs.

Ranking the Yankees most likely to be gone before the trade deadline

Harrison Bader

Knowing that the Yankees intend to supplement their roster and find (at least) a platoon partner for Jake Bauers/Billy McKinney, trading Gleyber Torres seems out of the question. Considering how unwilling the team has been to hand the job outright to Oswald Peraza, if they have designs on contending in 2024, they'll be keeping Torres. They certainly have those designs. He'd rank seventh here, with Clarke Schmidt in the No. 6 spot.

Bader is a free agent at the end of the season, and has been widely speculated as an extension candidate in New York. Did his price rise too high for the Yankees when he was sparking victories throughout April, May and June? Is it low enough to make sense for Brian Cashman that he's battled injuries and ineffectiveness this summer? Is a "moderate bat, high energy, impressive defense, poor health" center fielder worth a long-term financial commitment?

If the Yankees deem Bader to be a luxury, not a necessity, they might try to send him to a contender at the deadline. Who knows? He might even re-sign anyway with a handshake agreement. It seems more likely than not, though, that his future is too uncertain to make him a long-term Yankee.

Isiah Kiner-Falefa

As Billy McKinney and Jake Bauers have taken turns making surprising memories this season, Isiah Kiner-Falefa has gotten fewer and fewer starts (though he performed shockingly well at the plate in the absence of Aaron Judge, hitting .275 in June and .293 in July with above-average OPS+ marks in every month of the season besides April.

He makes $6 million this season, which is prorated down to $2 million for any team that could acquire him this summer. He's a free agent at the end of this season. He's done everything the Yankees have asked of him, including moving to the outfield despite having no experience at it. His inexperience, despite all his effort, has shone.

Will Kiner-Falefa be a Yankee beyond this season if he isn't dealt? Is there any chance New York extends an admittedly below-average bat and glues him to the bench/super utility role? He's good in that role, as long as he's kept out of center/left field (excepting emergencies). But is there really a middle ground for this team to keep a non-starter at ~$7-8 million, with all their other rising costs? He could continue his 2023 heater and make a contender in need of solid ABs very happy. Maybe Milwaukee comes calling? They're interested in Jon Berti. IKF can approximate his skill set.

Luis Severino

Luis Severino is the biggest-ticket item on this watchlist. His 2023 salary counts against the luxury tax for $12.25 million after the Yankees picked up his option for the season. He's rewarded their faith by scuffling in spring training, hitting the IL just before the campaign began, and returning without most of his fastball's trademark hop.

His past two starts entering Sunday's game have looked closer to fine, but on the season, he's subtracted nearly a win from the Yankees while maintaining a 1.730 WHIP and striking out less than a batter per inning. That should ... never happen from someone who regularly pumps 99 when healthy (he's also been sitting 95-96 on occasion, somehow losing his mechanics midstream).

With Nestor Cortes Jr. on the road to recovery, one of Severino, Clarke Schmidt and Domingo Germán will ideally be out of a rotation spot in the coming weeks. If some team dared to take a chance on capturing the best of Severino in August and September, and was also willing to take on enough of his salary to make it all make sense, the Yankees would surely wave the white flag on this brutal option year, despite recent strides. If they have to attach a big-ticket prospect to get it done, though -- or absorb all the money -- expect New York's braintrust to ride it out and try to sell a different starter instead.

Domingo Germán

There's no "selling high" quite like trying to sell someone who just threw a perfect game at the end of June.

Domingo Germán is what he is, at this point. The Yankees cynically stuck with him through a domestic violence suspension because the arm talent is there. Since his return in 2021, that much has been clear ... for two-or-three-start stretches at a time, before he deposits an all-time stinker and can't harness his breakers.

Germán has a 4.77 ERA for a reason this season. He had a 4.58 mark in 2021 for a reason. He had a 3.61 ERA in 72.1 innings with a 4.44 FIP last season for a reason. This is who he is.

He's also shut down the Dodgers on Sunday Night Baseball this season, perfecto'd the A's, and dominated the Twins with 6.1 innings of 11-K baseball. That is also who he is (though, yes, he was suspended again this season for an over-sticky hand).

Germán's salary is only $2.6 million for the season, and a Germán trade alone will not clear the cash the Yankees need to get rid of. He's controllable for the next year and a half, though, which is tangibly attractive. He'll spin gems. He'll get tattooed (10 runs to the Mariners preceded his perfect game). He'll tantalize. He'll frustrate.

The Yankees print pitching, and their best long-term rotation (and playoff rotation) probably doesn't include Germán. If some team is willing to pay for the Dodger Stadium version of this roller coaster right-hander, the Yankees have to jump at the chance. He's the most likely Yankee to be on another team this week by far.