Remember after Giancarlo Stanton's trillionth calf strain of the 2026 season when we speculated that the New York Yankees had an out in his contract heading into the offseason? Well, it appears that they won't be taking it as the truncated offseason action begins to heat up.
Speaking to reporters at the General Manager Meetings in Las Vegas, Cashman confirmed that Stanton will "absolutely" be back in the Bronx for 2027.
“There’s never been a time when he’s healthy that he’s not been impactful. I know he can get streaky and all that stuff, but he’s an impact hitter. … So, hopefully, we’ll get a healthy Stanton. He’s a big presence in our clubhouse, a great leader. He’s wired right. He’s doing everything he possibly can to impact us in a real positive way."
Stanton was impactful ... in 2025. While he was limited to just 77 games, he hit 24 homers and slashed .273/.350/.594, posting his best wRC+ mark (157) since his MVP season all the way back in 2017. But just as we remember the moments when Stanton has been good, we'd be remiss not to mention the times when he's been a real negative.
Giancarlo Stanton will definitely be returning to the Yankees next season, GM Brian Cashman says, and still believes he’s a powerful impact bat
— Bob Nightengale (@BNightengale) November 10, 2026
The biggest example of this was 2023, when Stanton hit .191/.275/.420 over 101 contests. His wRC+ was just 88 and he subtracted 0.6 fWAR from the Yankees that season. While that's an extreme example from the big man's recent performance, we all know that the sizzling hot streaks come with deep valleys when he flails helplessly at a steady dose of sliders in the opposite batter's box.
“So, he’s not going anywhere. He’ll be in spring training with us without a doubt, and hopefully healthy and ready to go. And that’s his intention. He finished the season healthy. And the fact that Aaron Boone was calling his name in big moments, I think, answers the question of what we think he’s capable of when he is healthy,” Cashman added.
While this feels like a definitive, case-closed kind of statement, we have to wonder how serious Cashman is, especially given the fact that these comments are coming at the height of smokescreen season. The long-time GM isn't exactly a reliable source when it comes to laying out the team's plans in the winter. Remember when he unequivocally declared Bubba Crosby as New York's center fielder, just to turn around and sign Johnny Damon what felt like moments later?
There's a chance Brian Cashman's insistence on Giancarlo Stanton returning is a Yankees smokescreen
The Yankees' roster isn't built for Stanton to clog the DH spot every day. Not with Aaron Judge needing more time at DH to preserve his health, and not with the redundancy that Ben Rice and Luis Garcia Jr. provide. Sure, New York claims it will consider Garcia Jr. at a different position, but if his defense proves not to be up to snuff, it will create an awkward situation with Stanton unable to do anything but DH.
But maybe, just maybe, there's a grand plan in the works. See, despite all of the issues that Stanton presents, he's still a right-handed source of power, and those are scarce around the league these days. Previously, his contract was too onerous for anyone to consider taking on, but now in the final year of the deal, that might not be the case. The Marlins are paying $10 million of his $25 million salary in 2027, so for $15 million, could a power-needy team really pass up the opportunity?
There's another possibility at play, too. Cashman could use Stanton's contract to offset money in a deal to bring in a piece with more value to the Yankees. For example, Texas Rangers insider Evan Grant speculated that Stanton could be part of a Corey Seager trade as a means to give the Rangers some financial relief without them having to eat some of the star shortstop's contract.
In this scenario, the Yankees would be reliving the Alex Rodriguez trade by taking on Seager to play third base. That's certainly more useful than holding on to Stanton, despite the issues that Seager presents.
Overall, by coming out and making this declaration, Cashman could be trying to gain leverage in a potential trade, rather than signaling true intent to bring Stanton back next year. After all, why give up an asset for nothing if it still has some, albeit diminished, value? At least, this is what we hope the plan is. Time will tell.
