Bryce Harper's absurd demand should stop Yankees trade rumors before they begin

With Hal Steinbrenner throwing the New York Yankees' players under the bus and specifically taking aim at the offense, it's clear that the club needs a shakeup. It may be one of the few things that he and Aaron Judge agree on these days, though the way they'd both go about it would probably be different.

When it comes to augmenting the offense, it's easy to go back to old rumors to try to find solutions. One that might make Judge happy would be New York taking advantage of the uncertainty in Philadelphia and pulling off a trade for his buddy Bryce Harper.

Harper to the Yankees has been something that has simmered for years, though it was Brian Cashman who opted not to pursue the veteran slugger when he last hit the free-agent market.

Just by the numbers, Harper's .269/.380/.485 line and 29 homers would have lifted a Yankees lineup that was far too top-heavy in 2026. However, his showing in the playoffs was uninspiring both in terms of performance, with him striking out five times over 13 at-bats, and effort.

Even if you overlook the struggles during Philadelphia's quick playoff exit, coming to a deal would be tough. Not only would Cashman have to convince Phillies president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski to part with the star first baseman, but New York would also have to convince Harper to waive his no-trade clause.

Lost in the shuffle of Philadelphia's elimination was this nugget from Ken Rosenthal, who reported that the only way Harper wouldn't veto the trade is if the acquiring team were to hand him a contract extension. If this wasn't enough of an awkward fit to begin with, that revelation should make this a non-starter.

Giving Bryce Harper a contract extension to secure a trade to the Yankees is pure insanity

In case it's not clear, trading for Harper would be a bad idea based on how the roster is currently constructed. The Yankees already have one too many left-handed-hitting first basemen, so adding another to the mix would be ludicrous. There have been some rumblings that a position change could be in store for Luis Garcia Jr., but even then, balancing DH days for a 35-year-old Judge and a 34-year-old Harper along with Ben Rice is a tough task.

That wouldn't just be a one-year problem, either. Harper has four years and $98 million left on his contract. He'll complete his age-38 season when it ends in 2031. Extending him and paying him big money for his age-39 season and likely into his 40s is ludicrous.

We've already seen him settle into his decline phase, with his performance tailing off somewhat significantly from his prime years. By the end of his original 13-year, $330 million deal, it's questionable whether he'll even be an average hitter. Beyond that, well, yikes!

Bringing Harper in during the 2018-2019 offseason had a ton of merit, but now acquiring him is asking for trouble. Even ignoring all of the other red flags, what the Yankees would have to do to get him to waive his no-trade clause is a poison pill that they definitely shouldn't swallow.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow