Skip to main content

Brian Cashman’s comments on Spencer Jones create even more Yankees problems

What's the plan? A trade?
ByColin Keane
Spencer Jones.
Spencer Jones. | Elsa/GettyImages

New York Yankees general manager Brian Cashman has a long-held winter routine for discussing the organization's young trade chips. It goes something like this: If Player X is mentioned in trade buzz, Cashman makes a point to overly praise that player in the media, protect/boost the player's trade value, and refuse to lock the player into a role for the following season.

Cashman just went through these motions with Yankees outfielder Spencer Jones at GM Meetings (and then again on Thursday night). In discussing Jones, Cashman suggested to reporters that the Yankees don't believe the slugger's best position is center field.

Immediately, Yankees observers' minds were overwhelmed with a flurry of questions: Is Jones about to be traded? Is Cody Bellinger definitely moving to center field? And what does this mean for Heliot Ramos and Jasson Dominguez?

Brian Cashman's comments on Spencer Jones just created a mysterious forecast for the Yankees' 2027 outfield

There's surely a large segment of the Yankees fanbase that expected Jones to be the team's center fielder in 2027. Despite Jones' defensive shortcomings this past year, he's young and athletic, and working with the right help in the offseason could help him improve. Moving Bellinger to center is something that feels counterproductive, given the fact that Belli just won a Platinum Glove in left field.

But Cashman's comments just cast a shadow over the above vision. If you had to guess, it sounds like Cashman and the Yankees are planning on moving Bellinger to center, leaving right for Aaron Judge and left for whoever remains of Jones/Ramos/Dominguez once the smoke clears.

It's not like the free-agent center-field market is booming (stay away from Luis Robert Jr.!). Nor are there any trade targets at the position that stand out as logical for the Yankees. Cashman's reluctance to hand Jones the center field job — paired with no reveal about Bellinger's 2027 position — has us all waiting for what comes next. It won't be nothing.

Brian Cashman isn't wrong about Spencer Jones, but the Yankees still have an outfield problem

Jones is stronger in the corner outfield spots than in center at the moment. But to ignore his potential for growth in center to the extent of moving Bellinger there would feel panicky and hypocritical for a team that watched Trent Grisham play a severely uninspired center field for all of 2026.

Zooming out, none of the outfield alignments for the Yankees feel like a win-win. I've already reviewed the downside of a Jones-Bellinger-Judge lineup (with Belli in center). Trading Jones would free up a corner outfield spot, but now you've traded away a promising and controllable young bat. Trading Dominguez or Ramos hurts your depth.

It's a complicated puzzle that could best be solved by committing to Jones in center, but the Yankees don't seem like they're interested in such a plan.

Add us as a preferred source on Google