Aaron Boone's postgame quote on Austin Wells gaffe is exactly why some Yankees fans can't buy in

The very second we all collectively realized Austin Wells was cantering around second base as Taylor Walls whipped the baseball towards third for History's Easiest Out, you could hear the air leave the entire tri-state area. This horrific Yankees moment evoked different feelings for different fans.

In my eyes? This was another example of whatever syndrome afflicted the Yankees in Game 5 of the 2024 World Series. Embarrassing. White-knuckle nonsense. From the depths of hell. But that series was lost. This game wasn't dead and buried yet, but Wells' botch job certainly didn't dictate the loss; they carried limp pool noodles and wore blindfolds to the dish for eight full innings of Drew Rasmussen.

But the fanbase is split. Some blame moments like Wells' full send and Gerrit Cole's Game 5 brainlock squarely on the players. I am one of those fans. The desperation temporarily strips their rationality. They zone out. The let the Yankees' predicament too deep into their heads and they short-circuit. This is a roster-wide problem.

And there are other fans who blame inexplicable errors like these squarely on Aaron Boone and his "culture of coddling". I think that's goofy. The Yankees' impeccable chemistry just won them a playoff series against the hated Red Sox. It also doesn't take much Boone viewing to realize he does get agitated often. It leaks through. You know there's some form of that poking out behind closed doors. The alternative - regularly blasting his players to the media - is a silly fantasy that accomplishes nothing. I promise you that in no clubhouse is what Wells just did acceptable. Wells knows that. Boone doesn't have to kick a trash can to communciate that fact.

And yet ... when Boone strides to the mic and handles Wells' malfeasance by saying, "Obviously, it's a mistake - it does happen" ... you can see why there are still so many fans who assume that mistake is a symptom of whatever rot seems to take hold of the Yankees far more often than it should.

At least Boone didn't try to pull an excuse out of thin air - "He saw it bounding around the corner, Mesa really looked lost out there" - and he didn't try to cite a statistic that only the Yankees have access to - "We actually really liked Wellsy sprinting in that spot, our sprint speed has him a lot higher than you guys do".

It's understandable if you feel like there should be some sort of middle ground between blasting Wells to the media and equating that decision with aggression, though. How about, "In no world is that acceptable, and Austin knows it, too. He's better than that. He will be better than that. We believe in him. But that cannot happen"?

Stats show Austin Wells' decision to stretch a double into a triple was uniquely unhelpful

The reality is in the numbers. If Wells makes it to third base, without some kind of overthrow, he's increased his chances of scoring by ... 0.01 runs in the inning.

Maybe Boone could've split the difference, cited this statistic, and just given a hat-tip to the haters, acknowledging that Wells' mistake wasn't just normal aggression. It was unjustifiable. Them's should not have, in fact, been the breaks.

The Yankees just spent 18 innings being locked in against the Boston Red Sox, followed by their worst offensive effort of the season against a pitcher they can't seem to adjust to. Instead of rightly focusing on that horrific approach and turning it into a blip, fan vitriol has focused on Wells, and many of those fans believe his gaffe is a symptom of Boone's reign.

Just watch. The same people who would've pilloried Boone if he changed the Game 2 lineup that worked so well against Boston are probably flaming him anyway for letting Drew Rasmussen settle into a groove against all lefties.

He's stuck in a difficult-to-navigate situation, taking blame regardless of how he appears in front of the camera and whether he chooses to act or stay back. But ... still ... when you see a postgame like this, you start to understand how some fans can get so single-minded.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow