5 Yankees on 40-man roster who won’t last all of 2023

As it stands at this moment, the New York Yankees‘ 40-man roster is full. But that doesn’t prevent them from making more moves this offseason once the trade market materializes, allowing the front office to potentially swing deals for bullpen arms or outfielders.

Even if that doesn’t happen, it’s hard to see this 40-man roster remaining static for the entirety of 2023, especially with so many players hanging on by a thread. It also wouldn’t be surprising if we saw some axed from the active roster if/when push comes to shove.

While the Yankees upgraded for the 2023 season, their offense still has a lot of question marks. Will Josh Donaldson become … average? Is DJ LeMahieu healthy? Who will play left field? What’s Gleyber Torres’ status/future? Will Oswald Peraza be an immediate fit at shortstop? Will Giancarlo Stanton be able to last a full season?

Right now, the only constant forces feel like Aaron Judge, Anthony Rizzo, Harrison Bader and Jose Trevino, from an all-around baseball perspective. And that really won’t be good enough.

It’s totally fine if the Yankees enter 2023 with the collection of players they have at this point in time, but it’d be criminal if we’re looking at the same group even midway through the year if there appear to be bumps in the road.

These 5 players on the Yankees’ 40-man roster might not make it through 2023

5. Aaron Hicks

Hicks comes in at No. 5 because it still feels unlikely he’s traded (who will make a deal for him?) or released in the near future. The Yankees aren’t going to wave the white flag in trade talks, nor will they willingly eat the remaining money on Hicks’ contract (~$30 million).

But if he draws the ire of the fanbase again with his poor play, lack of hustle and uninspiring body language? The Yankees might not have a choice — kind of like this offseason when Hal Steinbrenner went the extra mile to re-sign Judge, add Carlos Rodón, and bring back Tommy Kahnle as the groans grew louder.

Nobody’s even penciling in Hicks as the starting left fielder for 2023 despite the fact there’s an obvious vacancy. He’ll be competing for the job with minor-league invites to spring training. He profiles as a bench player/fourth outfielder, but he’s getting paid like a middling starter.

This situation has already reached a boiling point. When it fully spills over, the Yankees may not be left with any other decision than to find a way to offload him no matter the cost.

3. Ben Rortvedt

It seems as if we’re endlessly reminded of the disastrous Josh Donaldson-Isiah Kiner-Falefa “blockbuster” trade with the Minnesota Twins. While the Yankees got rid of Gary Sánchez — something they could’ve done without a trade and saved $9 million — they swapped Gio Urshela for Donaldson, whose performances were pretty much night and day (especially from an offensive perspective) in 2022.

Catcher Ben Rortvedt was the final piece of that deal and he wowed upon arrival with his meaty biceps. Unfortunately, knee surgery followed by an oblique injury wiped out his 2022 season. He was on the Yankees roster for a hot second but never appeared in a game. He played 48 games between Single-A, High-A and Triple-A, but hit just .218 with a .705 OPS.

Fans can’t imagine his leash is long, especially with the catching situation already set. Jose Trevino will start, Kyle Higashioka will back him up — and both of them have at least two more years of club control remaining.

Unless Rortvedt does a total 180 and becomes an overnight masher, the Yankees would likely much rather give any potential backup reps (in the event of an injury or trade) to guys like Austin Wells and Josh Breaux — both of whom have limited MLB experience, just like Rortvedt.

The only reason for keeping Rortvedt on the 40-man is to avoid starting the service-time clocks for those two prospects since they’re not quite ready yet. But a few more months of development could convince the Yankees otherwise if Rortvedt falters while Wells and Breaux flourish.

2. Albert Abreu

Per delusional Yankees Twitter, Albert Abreu is “tearing it up” in the Dominican Winter League. His line? 3.27 ERA, 1.55 WHIP and nine strikeouts in 11 innings of work. Some folks just happened to catch one nasty slider/changeup and convinced themselves that he has “potential.”

How much longer are we willing to wait on that, though? Baseball-Reference hawks will head on over to his page and try to justify his 22-game showing in New York last year. Or they might point to his impressive August back in 2021.

But that isn’t enough for a reliever the Yankees ostensibly hope to count on. If Abreu stays to pick up the trash in mop-up duty, then fine. If he’s ever utilized in a high-leverage situation when it’s not an absolute emergency, then the Yankees are beating a dead horse.

Abreu, 27, has time and time again proven that he’s incapable of harnessing consistency. Not every reliever needs to be a sub-4.00 ERA arm … but they certainly can’t oscillate from somewhat serviceable to batting practice.

With a few younger arms hoping to make an impact in the bullpen at the onset of 2023 (and as the season progresses), look for Abreu to be the odd man out later in the year (if the Yankees don’t make the decision prior to Opening Day).

1. Deivi Garcia

Not to be rude, but what’s the wait on cutting Deivi Garcia loose? Oh … we know! It’s the Yankees’ famous tendency to never admit defeat, even if it means shooting themselves in the foot. Then the knee. Then the chest. Then the head.

After an impressive six-start stint in the shortened 2020, Garcia fell off the face of the earth. He appeared in two MLB games in 2021, logged a 6.48 ERA and 1.44 WHIP, and never returned. In 2021 at Triple-A, he finished with a 6.85 ERA and 1.88 WHIP across 24 games (22 starts), totaling 90.2 innings. And it somehow got worse in 2022.

Between Double-A (yup, he was demoted!) and Triple-A, Garcia finished with a 6.89 ERA, 1.44 WHIP and 76 strikeouts in 20 games (13 starts), totaling 64 innings. He’s been on the 40-man roster since 2020! He owns a 5.27 ERA in the majors and a 4.58 ERA in the minors! What?!

Garcia’s apparently lost touch with his mechanics and it’s unclear how he can be salvaged. But the Yankees will keep beating the drum until the last possible strike of the clock. Right now, holding onto him feels beyond irresponsible because he can’t even be called upon to eat up meaningless innings in the big leagues.

If he’s not gone before Opening Day, perhaps a slow start to year does him in. Either way, the Yankees have no more time to waste with Garcia, who will hopefully find his footing elsewhere if it continues to not work out here.

3 sneaky left field options Yankees can still pursue to fill vacancy

The New York Yankees have many potential left field options still on the market in front of them, but these 3 sneaky options deserve attention.