3 players we can’t believe Yankees didn’t trade at 2022 deadline

No. 1 on the list? Joey Gallo! How did he not go anywhere?! Just kidding. He was extremely traded. Beyond traded. Traded as much as a Yankees player can be traded. He’ll receive a fresh start in Los Angeles, and his beard growth already appears to be at a Level 3.

But even though the Yanks shipped Gallo west, that was … just about the only obvious move they completed. They dealt nearly every healthy upper-level pitching prospect they had in their possession for the Cubs’ Scott Effross and the A’s Frankie Montas and Lou Trivino. They swung a deal with three lower-level prospects for Andrew Benintendi. And, out of nowhere, they whipped Jordan Montgomery to St. Louis in exchange for injured center fielder Harrison Bader.

With all that shuffling, how did they possibly hold onto these three guys?

New York’s farm is still extremely top-heavy with elite talent, even though the middle has been thinned out a bit. What that means, though, is that the Triple-A team is still overflowing with guys who probably deserve a big-league shot, but seemingly won’t get one with the 2022 Bombers, after not getting one in 2021 and 2020 either.

The Yankees had a few assets they could’ve sold high on, but didn’t. They had a tippy-top prospect who’s blocked from behind (?) who we could’ve sworn would’ve been involved in an upper-echelon package. They had a player stuck in neutral who’s begging to get out who Brian Cashman did not reward in any capacity.

Now, the dust has settled, and all three are still here.

3 players we can’t believe Yankees didn’t trade at 2022 MLB Trade Deadline

3. Miguel Andújar

When Miguel Andújar was demoted in early June after serving as what seemed like a key cog in the Yankees’ machine for several weeks, that became his final straw. After being sent down mid-Tigers series, he requested a trade while en route to Scranton.

You’ll never guess whether that trade materialized.

While Andújar felt like a reliable option during his 2022 tenure in New York, the numbers actually indicated he was less than effective; he hit .245, but only OPS’d .555 for a 60 OPS+. Andújar should be commended on learning the outfield and getting comfortable (and ended up being worth a positive 0.2 WAR!), but his bat wasn’t the boon that fans fighting against injustice made it out to be.

It’s clear, at this point, that Andújar is unlikely to return much in any trade. It’s also clear, though, that the Yankees have no long-term, big-league plan for him. If flipped, the 27-year-old and his helicopter swing would probably only return cash and a lottery-ticket prospect … but that’s more valuable to the Bombers than increasing Scranton/Wilkes-Barre’s winning percentage.

Andújar is already a distressed asset, but he’s not getting any younger at Triple-A. It’s stunning he’s still in the pipeline.

1. Oswald Peraza

Consider this more of an exhale than a declaration, but how on earth did the Yankees get a Frankie Montas (and more!) deal done without including their second-best shortstop prospect in the package?

For months, it’s felt like either Oswald Peraza would get traded or Oswald Peraza would get promoted to the bigs and send Isiah Kiner-Falefa back into the utility role he’s always been destined for. The team believes in Anthony Volpe. The team believes in Gleyber Torres (unless…?). The team believes in, and extended, DJ LeMahieu. There are only so many infield slots to go around, and only one shortstop can play at a time.

Picking between Peraza and Volpe, then dealing the non-chosen one for a major upgrade that could bring a World Series to the Bronx in 2022, seemed like the logical endpoint of this deadline. And yet … Luis Castillo went elsewhere, Montas came to the Bronx, and Peraza’s still waiting for a ticket on the Scranton Shuttle.

In recent weeks, the 22-year-old has caught fire, raising his Triple-A totals to .256 with a .769 OPS, 14 bombs and 26 stolen bases. “Respectable”? Lately, he’s been special.

There’s still a second-half spot waiting for him in the Boogie Down if the Yankees want to give their roster a jolt in the middle of their recent pennant-race doldrums. It’s unbelievable the team still has that choice to make, though. How did he not end up in Cincinnati or at the Coliseum?

If the Mariners don’t drop Noelvi Marte into their package for Castillo, Peraza’s likely in the Queen City. Ideally, the Yankees take full advantage of their second chance with him.

Grading Yankees’ transformative 2022 MLB trade deadline moves

The New York Yankees pulled off a number of swaps at the 2022 MLB Trade Deadline, so we've graded the moves, from Benintendi to Gallo.