5 replacements for Yankees’ Domingo German after shoulder injury

Did the Yankees really think carrying Domingo German as their rotational “depth” option to back up Luis Severino and Jameson Taillon was a wise decision?

On the one hand, German doesn’t hold a candle to Severino in talent and can’t match Taillon’s consistency, but on the other, he was out for the vast majority of the second half of 2021 with shoulder inflammation. So who could’ve seen a shoulder impingement that landed him on the 60-Day IL to start 2022 coming?! Everyone other than the people responsible for sniffing it out, it seems.

According to Aaron Boone and the Yankees, German actually feels well enough to throw at the moment and continues to assure the team brass that he’s on the mend. The issue, though, is that his throwing program essentially begins now, and with a roster spot in need of clearance, German was an obvious choice.

The issue wasn’t German’s unavailability. The issue was that the Yanks somehow thought the volatile German would be their steady backup plan. Last season, German was elite in goading opposing hitters into chasing pitches out of the zone, but often surrendered hard contact when his pitches floated into swing paths. The Yankees can and should do better.

So … he’s out. Predictably. For quite a while. How do the Yanks reassess? They hadn’t really prepared for this test, for whatever reason.

There are a few internal replacements who come to mind. There’s precious little on the free agent market. And, most importantly, there are a couple of lingering high-profile trade targets, either of whom would provide much more than just “innings” … if that’s a direction thee Yankees feel comfortable going in. Will every prospect be a Yankee prospect forever? Did trading Roansy Contreras re-scar Brian Cashman for life? It’s worth wondering.

For now, these are New York’s most viable options for thickening out the rotation in April and May. Apologies to free agents like Cole Hamels, who are just as unreliable as German at this juncture, someone who is literally out for months.

Yankees could use these 4 replacements for Domingo German

5 and 4. Deivi Garcia/Clarke Schmidt/The Equivalent

We’ve balled up the Yankees’ internal options into a combination of these two, and the conversation doesn’t go far beyond them. As interesting as it would be to see Ken Waldichuk or Hayden Wesneski get the bump every five days, that’s not a realistic desire, even as both men get some shine this spring.

In most years, the Yankees will have imported a somewhat-familiar name as a minor-league contract flyer at this point. Remember Asher Wojciechowski? This season, not so much; most of their minor-league attention has been paid to veteran position players like Ender Inciarte and Marwin Gonzalez.

So, it’s Deivi Garcia or Clarke Schmidt, per our estimation. Garcia’s 2021 season must never be spoken of again, after he was the clear highest man on the totem pole less than a year prior. Despite several strong starts during the summer of 2020, a poor outing against the Red Sox at the end of the campaign pushed his ERA up to 4.98. In ’21, things didn’t go according to even the most modest of plans; Garcia lost the plate and ended up with an unsightly 6.85 ERA in 90.2 innings pitched, completing the hideous picture with 68 walks … at Triple-A!

Schmidt got the Scranton Shuttle treatment in 2021 after a long wait and some bad injury luck when he tried to ramp up too early in Spring Training. Ultimately, in 6.1 innings (two outings, one start), he posted an ungodly WHIP of 2.526 after being tossed into an unpleasant situation.

Whether you believe the recent body of work is fair or unfair as an assessment of these two players is up to you, but New York should probably do better to secure these missing innings.

2 and 1. Frankie Montas/Sean Manaea

Now, Yankees, listen closely here. You should absolutely trade for either Frankie Montas or Sean Manaea, two of the final pieces on the A’s Yard Sale table.

You should not finally deploy your entire pile of assets in either of these deals, overpaying in prospect capital just because everybody made fun of you for not doing so earlier.

Montas, after all, has ace upside and flop downside, striking out 207 men in 187 innings last year after a 5.60 ERA implosion in 2020 with a PED suspension mixed in (80 games back in 2019). Manaea’s metrics from 2021 were all over the place, and he might just be a reliable No. 4 in a more fire-breathing package.

Either would help the Yankees on some days and drastically hurt them on others. We’d applaud both acquisitions, but wouldn’t sacrifice more than a single top-five prospect in a Montas deal, and wouldn’t even want to dip into that area for Manaea — and the competition here is very high.

The frustrating thing about this Yankees offseason is just how easily it’s taught us all to examine all the warts on potential acquisitions before they’re made, from Carlos Correa to Trevor Story to the Oakland pitching duo. Trying to implore the Yankees to use their monetary advantage in free agency rather than their prospect supply on the trade market could alleviate some of this risk, but still … when the team lets past bad decisions block future moves, that’s not so easy either.

If you ask us? The solution to the German Problem isn’t in the building right now, and probably the best-case scenario is adding one of these Athletics. But don’t overpay just to do it.

Carlos Rodón’s fiery Twitter response shows he would’ve been perfect fit for Yankees

The New York Yankees passed on Carlos Rodón after he signed with the San Francisco Giants. Turns out he would've been a great fit in the Bronx.