3 Yankees college baseball draft targets to watch during MLB lockout

OMAHA, NEBRASKA - JUNE 30: Logan Tanner #19 of the Mississippi St. rounds the bases after hitting a solo home run against Vanderbilt in the top of the seventh inning during game three of the College World Series Championship at TD Ameritrade Park Omaha on June 30, 2021 in Omaha, Nebraska. (Photo by Sean M. Haffey/Getty Images)
OMAHA, NEBRASKA - JUNE 30: Logan Tanner #19 of the Mississippi St. rounds the bases after hitting a solo home run against Vanderbilt in the top of the seventh inning during game three of the College World Series Championship at TD Ameritrade Park Omaha on June 30, 2021 in Omaha, Nebraska. (Photo by Sean M. Haffey/Getty Images)
2 of 3
Next
Dylan Beavers of Cotuit makes a catch at the wall on a ball hit by #25 of Hyannis Cotuit Cape League
Dylan Beavers of Cotuit makes a catch at the wall on a ball hit by #25 of Hyannis Cotuit Cape League /

The 2022 MLB season is on permanent hiatus, and much like KBO action in early 2020 during the pandemic’s infancy, college baseball has stepped up to fill the void this season (as long as you have ESPN+ access).

For Yankees fans, this means a way-too-early pivot into draft season, which brings us to an impossible-to-predict ’22 slate.

Slotted 25th overall in the first round, New York will be caught in the eternal “draft for need, or draft the best player available?” debate, and they’ve used several top picks (and coveted international bonus money) these past several years on shortstops. Would they quadruple down and go back to that well, just to deepen the pool again? Or will they put their chips in on the best player who’s fallen into their range, high school or college?

Prior to the past few years, the Yankees have often gone with a highly-ranked high school arm when slotted towards the back of the first round — and, in fact, that’s who Baseball America recommends they target, singling out Brebeuf Jesuit Prep RHP Andrew Dutkanych as the selection.

We’d also advise fans to be wary of another “classic Yankees maneuver”: the injured arm who’s in the “setback” phase ahead of a “major comeback,” someone who never would’ve slipped otherwise. The team pulled this one off with Clarke Schmidt back in 2017, who was midway through his Tommy John rehab when selected. Many also thought the Yankees would end up with Ole Miss’ Gunnar Hoaglund last season for similar reasons, though Toronto ultimately selected the slipping, former-top-10-projected arm.

This time around, the “injured” option is Arkansas right-hander Peyton Pallette, who will miss the 2022 season with Tommy John rehab and is often projected to be selected towards the back of the first round regardless.

The Yankees will surely consider Pallette at 25, but he doesn’t qualify for this list, considering he cannot be watched!

Instead, fans should keep an eye on these three names that keep ending up in the Yankees’ range.

3 college baseball players Yankees fans should watch ahead of 2022 MLB Draft

3. Dylan Beavers, University of California, Berkeley

Dylan Beavers resides at a level just below the top college outfield bats, like James Madison’s Chase DeLauter, and just ahead of bats with one questionable tool, like swing-and-miss power source Jud Fabian, drafted by the Red Sox in the second round in 2021, but now back and mashing at Florida.

Just Baseball’s first Mock Draft pitched Beavers to the Yankees at 25, and the outfielder also ranks in the No. 24 spot on MLB Pipeline’s Top 100 Draft Prospects list. There’s certainly enough smoke placing Beavers in the desired range before the 2022 season really gets in gear, and there’s ample runway left for Baseball America’s preseason second-team All-American to make his mark.

Seven games into his junior season, Beavers is hitting .321 with a .412 OBP and three bombs, coming on the heels of a summer dip into the wood-bat showcase league on Cape Cod (during which he scuffled, hitting .233 in just eight games).

Beavers will need to continue to strike the ball with authority and show off his in-game power to get the Christian Yelich comparisons that once dogged him back to centerstage, but he’s a 20-year-old prototypical five-tool outfielder who bats left. As long as he continues to produce at something approximating his current pace, the Yankees will be interested — unless Helium Alert takes him out of their range.

Tennessee’s Blade Tidwell (29) pitches against Florida
Tennessee’s Blade Tidwell (29) pitches against Florida /

2. Blade Tidwell, University of Tennessee

If it’s a top collegiate arm who’s not injured the Yankees are after, the target could be Blade Tidwell. The Tennessee Volunteers star has rocketed up MLB Pipeline’s big board to No. 13, but Baseball America foresees him still being available when the Yanks select at 25.

Focusing on something other than how awesome Tidwell’s name is remains a Herculean task, but there’s a lot to like about his profile, too.

Amateur arms are particularly difficult to project, but Tidwell’s rock-solid, 6-4, 240-pound frame seems easier to forecast than a high schooler who’s still growing/gaining control of his breaking stuff. As a freshman, Tidwell started the clinching game that sent the Vols to their first College World Series berth in Omaha in 16 seasons, showing unique poise for his age. He also paired well with fellow top pick Ryan Weathers back in his high school rotation; Weathers (son of David, if you’re looking for Yankees ties) has since ascended to the big leagues at an extremely young age with the Padres.

This might shock you (it won’t), but Tidwell is also among the many amateur pitching prospects battling an injury right now. His shoulder soreness has caused him to miss the start of the season, but he will reportedly not need surgery to solve the issue, like so many of his other cohorts.

If and when Tidwell returns, the Yankees should cross their fingers that he slipped just enough to get to them as a draft-eligible sophomore, especially since there are so many other heavy-hitters at the back end of the first round (and you know Tidwell could be a Dodgers or Red Sox risk).

Logan Tanner #19 and Jackson Fristoe #27 of the Mississippi St. (Photo by Sean M. Haffey/Getty Images)
Logan Tanner #19 and Jackson Fristoe #27 of the Mississippi St. (Photo by Sean M. Haffey/Getty Images) /

1. Logan Tanner, Mississippi State

If the Yankees do draft for need … there’s no need greater than behind the plate, and it’s much easier to project a catcher moving forward (in both tangibles and intangibles) than it is to figure out what a pitcher will eventually become.

Logan Tanner, projected by Baseball America to head to the Red Sox (eesh) and slotted 19th overall by MLB Pipeline, is exactly the kind of high-upside and high floor catcher the Yankees could prioritize at 25. He’d be both an appropriate value and a need-filler, as long as everything goes right in his developmental path.

In 2021, Tanner led the Mississippi State Bulldogs with 15 homers and led them to a College World Series title, neatly completing his full resume in just a single season. Projected for 55 power (on an 80-max scouting scale) and equipped with a rocket 70 arm (he was once a two-way prospect and logged some mound time), the slugging catcher already has both championship experience and counting numbers on his ledger — not to mention guiding Miss State’s extremely talented 2021 pitching staff, led by 2021 Giants first-rounder Will Bednar and closer-turned-first-round-starter prospect Landon Sims.

Tanner has started off 2022 hitting .280 with a bomb in seven games, and thanks to the pedigree of the team he’s leading, Yankee fans will have ample opportunity to watch him this season as compared with similar prospects.

If you’re dreaming of a 6-0, 215-pound force behind home plate, Tanner might be your ideal (and attainable) selection — as long as the Sox don’t swipe him one pick early.

Hey, come to think of it … why exactly do the Sox pick ahead of the Yankees when they won the tiebreaker and hosted the Wild Card Game?!

Next