3 Yankees prospects who could steal roster spots at spring training

Somerset Patriots batter Oswaldo Cabrera hit a two-run homer against the Erie SeaWolves on June 9, 2021, at UPMC Park in Erie.P2seawolves060921
Somerset Patriots batter Oswaldo Cabrera hit a two-run homer against the Erie SeaWolves on June 9, 2021, at UPMC Park in Erie.P2seawolves060921
1 of 3
Next
A detail view of New York Yankees baseball hat at George M. Steinbrenner Field. Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports
A detail view of New York Yankees baseball hat at George M. Steinbrenner Field. Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports /

The New York Yankees are going to have some roster spots up for grabs this spring — and, if things don’t reverse course quickly, that number could climb into the double digits.

Kidding. Being facetious. We think.

As of this moment, the Yanks have vacancies at short, center, first (?), on the bench, in the rotation, and in the bullpen. Many of those will be filled by trades and signings once activity is again sanctioned post-lockout. As of now, all of that activity has been shut down (unless you’re the Astros trying to sign Justin Verlander pretty please).

But for the middle portions of the ‘pen, back of the rotation, and utility roles? We’ve got our eyes firmly trained on internal options, considering the Yankees went out of their way to focus our attention there a few weeks back when they scrambled to protect several players from the Rule 5 Draft that never happened.

If you can recall back to a time when maneuvers were legal, the Yankees DFA’d Clint Frazier, Rougned Odor and Tyler Wade while also trading Nick Nelson and Donny Sands to clear out five extra roster spots. Most of the players added feel like genuine threats to swipe playing time in 2022.

And, remember, there’s one other way that players who are not on the 40-man can find their way to MLB and break camp with the team. If a player hits the 60-Day IL (and, believe us, it will happen), their roster spot is up for grabs, and the Yankees can select anyone they’d like to the 40-man (and then the active roster). For example, Zack Britton will be hitting the long-term Injured List, clearing a path for someone to travel north with the team.

Well, travel to … Dallas, TX for Opening Day, actually. Dallas! Classic Opening Day location. It’s like MLB knew Corey Seager and Marcus Semien were heading there.

When the Yankees and Rangers face off, don’t be stunned if these three players are in attendance — including one wild card, Lucas Luetge style.

3 unexpected prospects who could make Yankees’ Opening Day roster.

3. JP Sears, LHP

Though his 40-man protection likely shocked you, it’s clear the Yankees believe 25-year-old left-hander JP Sears has a chance to stick on an MLB roster for the entire 2022 season.

All that being said … he’s almost un-Googleable. You ask for the pitcher, you get a “right-wing American YouTuber”? Uh … don’t check for yourself. Clearly, the lefty Sears’ relevance better get a significant upgrade — and fast — and breaking camp with the Yanks will be an easy way to make that happen.

Following in Luetge’s footsteps, the 25-year-old Mariners draftee wowed with soft stuff that ticks up last season, posting a 10-2 record with a 3.46 ERA in 25 games (18 starts) last season. Across Double-A and Triple-A (and he was better in Scranton), Sears whiffed 136 men in 104 innings pitched.

There’s a lot to like here.

Sears will have the simplest path to a big-league opportunity this spring of anyone listed. Without Britton, this bullpen already needs to go one man deeper than it did last year. If New York’s looking for a cut-and-dried left-handed replacement, it might just be their 40-man’s newest member. It’s all about impressing when the spotlight is on you, just like Luetge did, but Sears has an obvious chance to make the leap.

Yankee fans looks on as Corey Kluber throws in the bullpen ahead of the WooSox game against Scranton on Tuesday, August 17, 2021. Loc Woosox 817 17
Yankee fans looks on as Corey Kluber throws in the bullpen ahead of the WooSox game against Scranton on Tuesday, August 17, 2021. Loc Woosox 817 17 /

2. Matt Krook

Who? Matt Krook? Matt Krook? Am I hearing you right?

Yup! Matt Krook. Off the 40-man and into your hearts, he’s my off-the-wall pick for a prospect nobody’s talking about who could make noise this spring. Not in the same way that, say, Luis Medina makes noise by being glove-poppingly loud with his fastball, but in a slow and steady, professional manner.

Krook, a fourth-round pick out of Oregon by the Giants back in 2016, put up an impressive season in his first summer in pinstripes in 2021, but found his progress buried by several flashier stories. Across two levels (Double-A and Triple-A, two pitching hotbeds for this team), Krook allowed a minuscule 66 hits in 106 innings, allowing a .147 batting average against in Somerset and a .185 mark in Scranton.

Slinging it from the left side (again, what’d we tell you?), Krook isn’t the highest-ceiling option on the menu, but his numbers at the upper levels don’t lie, and he could theoretically make the leap from non-roster invitee to the mainstream.

Oh, and in case you wanted the story to be juicier, Krook was sent to the Tampa Bay Rays in the Evan Longoria trade, then toiled at Double-A for several seasons before finally making his first appearance at the minors’ highest level last year with the Yanks. How’d he get here? Stolen in the Triple-A phase of the Rule 5 prior to the 2021 campaign.

If we could simply … start Whitlocking the Rays and paying the favor forward, that would be absolutely great.

Oswaldo Cabrera #98 of the New York Yankees (Photo by Michael Reaves/Getty Images)
Oswaldo Cabrera #98 of the New York Yankees (Photo by Michael Reaves/Getty Images) /

1. Oswaldo Cabrera

OK, maybe we should clarify. When we said earlier that Sears had the best chance to make the roster in Britton’s place simply because it’s an easier path for pitchers, maybe we should’ve walked that back.

Because when the Yankees let Tyler Wade go, signed nobody to rotate around the infield, and promoted Oswaldo Cabrera to the 40-man, they were basically rolling out the red carpet for the kid to make the Opening Day roster, providing more bench pop than Wade ever could with the same level of versatility.

The 22-year-old Cabrera (yes, he’s still just 22, too!) tapped into his power in a huge way last season, despite being overshadowed by Oswald Peraza and Anthony Volpe at short. The kid rocked 29 bombs in 467 at-bats spent mostly at Double-A, though he did manage a remarkable five additional homers in just nine games at the Triple-A level at the end of the season.

The speedy Cabrera brings everything Wade theoretically did, plus emergent pop that’s only likely to increase as he fills out more. With so many of the Yankees’ infield plans in flux, from Gio Urshela’s job security to DJ LeMahieu’s role to Gleyber Torres’ future, odds are Cabrera finds himself in the roster conversation sooner rather than later.

In fact, we’d go so far as to say he’s the favorite this spring, as long as New York doesn’t sign, say, Jonathan Villar to keep his seat warm for a year.

Next