Yankees: 3 hybrid trades NYY can make with bizarre Braves
What are the Atlanta Braves? Why are they stuck in mud, just like the Yankees, but became the first team to make a real buy on Thursday night when they cut the line and traded for Joc Pederson?
Do they believe in themselves or are they putting a bandaid on a hole in the Hoover Dam just for kicks?
Meanwhile … what are the New York Yankees?!
Are they the consensus AL favorite for the World Series? Are they destined to remain unlucky forever, always placing men on base but never sending them home? After 90 games, are the advanced stats simply telling a story we’d rather read, instead of indicating a bounce back that’s yet to come?
In short, how do both the Braves and Yankees fix this? Whatever happens this year, neither is punting 2022.
Both teams are in a remarkably similar place — and, frankly, have been for decades. By and large, they bring superior talent to the table every year. They win large chunks of games, often in a row. When October arrives, they play a round or two before giving way to the deeper teams or the squads that got that extra, delightful bounce.
The 2021 versions of both teams have robust farm systems below the surface (and the Yankees’ farm, in particular, has shone this year in sometimes unexpected ways). They have established veteran stars, as well as still-pre-prime youngsters under contract for a long, long time (Atlanta’s Ozzie Albies deal remains an all-time steal).
The main differences? The Braves, though they begin the second half under .500, play in a more winnable division, led by the 60-percent-there Mets. The Yankees are nearly buried in the AL East, playing for the Wild Card despite their superior record to Atlanta. Additionally, the Braves have a major star hitting free agency this winter in Freddie Freeman as well as a centerpiece rehabbing from a surgical procedure (Ronald Acuña Jr., sadly), two caveats that don’t apply to the Yanks’ roster.
These three trades, ranging from fanciful to realistic, could address both teams’ needs and help next year’s reload.
Could the Braves and Yankees engage in these 3 hybrid trades?
3. The Extreme Longshot: Freddie Freeman for Luke Voit + Prospects
Freddie Freeman, an All-Star left-handed bat and still just 31, could be a monstrous solution to New York’s unbalanced lineup.
Yes, this would be another long-term, high-dollar extension in the making. The Yankees would never even consider this without an extension pledge. But boy, would it be a beautiful fit.
This exceedingly unlikely outcome would doubtlessly inject life into the Yanks’ future, and with six or seven additional years baked in, the package heading to Atlanta would not underwhelm. Luke Voit is no slouch, leading the American League in home runs in 2020, still just 30, and under control through 2024. In terms of prospects added, potentially Estevan Florial, Josh Smith and Luis Medina could polish off the package (with a lottery ticket thrown in as well)?
Your trade proposal sucks, my trade proposal sucks, we know this. But at least this one is almost laughing at itself as it gets written.
Freeman will be a Brave for life, in all likelihood, but he’d also be a generational and underrated star with three or four prime years left who could balance the Yankees’ lineup and take full advantage of the short porch in this “fantasy league” scenario. Coming off an MVP win, this is the worst season he’s posted since 2012, and he still sports a 127 OPS+. His humble nature will be beloved by whatever city he wraps his career in, but he might be the player I’d draft first overall given the chance to add any ideal fit to the Yankees’ roster (Tatis Jr. excepted). His free agency could be a rare opportunity to take advantage of his availability, if Brian Cashman is feeling daring.
2. The Fresh Start: Clint Frazier and Prospect for Cristian Pache
At the end of 2020, Clint Frazier was the Yankees’ Gold Glove-nominated starting left fielder. Cristian Pache was the Braves’ next Acuña, able to display his electric bat unexpectedly during the team’s postseason run.
Now? Some significant shine is off Pache, and Frazier seems like someone who just … needs to go home again.
If we could choose a destination for the Georgia-born outfielder to revive his career, it would certainly be in Atlanta, but the vertigo (?)-suffering slugger is still not a match for the recently-demoted Pache, who’s just 22 (and coming off hitting .111 in 22 MLB games this season, followed by .250 at Triple-A Gwinnett).
In order to bank on Pache’s potential bounce back, the Yanks will have to attach some pedigree to their fallen slugger — and it wouldn’t hurt if that ammunition came from the 40-man. Pitchers Yoendrys Gomez and Alex Vizcaino seem like prime candidates (ranked eighth and ninth on MLB Pipeline’s prospect list), and you can’t count out a Rule-5 eligible talent who isn’t yet on the 40-man being included, too. This might go three deep, but the Yankees would be wise to select only from players who need protection this offseason — hence Miguel Yajure moving for Jameson Taillon, for example.
Pache has less pedigree than Taillon, but also isn’t attempting to come back from anything nearly as intimidating (though one could say regression and unfulfilled potential are even less predictable than injury recovery). That Pirates trade was costly. This one might be, too, but the Yanks should still entertain it.
1. The Realistic Swap: Charlie Morton and Johan Camargo for Deivi Garcia, Vizcaino and Miguel Andújar
The only way to avoid facing Charlie Morton in a big game is to trade for Charlie Morton. Everyone knows this.
This is a bit of a fantasy trade, too, but all the pieces match if Atlanta’s given two high-upside arms to replace their departing current ace (who they can also re-sign at year’s end, if they’d like).
Thought of as a potential mid-rotation calming presence as recently as last fall, Deivi Garcia has completely lost the corners of the plate in 2021, struggling with both control and command at Triple-A in a season that’s removed some of his shine. Vizcaino is still a top-10 prospect (on the 40-man) who the Yankees believe in, despite the fact that several pitchers have emerged behind him who’ll be forcing the team’s hand in the years to come, like Ken Waldichuk and Luis Gil. Camargo, once a key switch-hitting bench piece infielder/outfielder for the Braves, has barely appeared this year but is still just 27.
Andújar? He’s appeared often, and he’s mostly played left field, which is not something he should be doing on a regular basis. His confusing time with the Yankees could be ending, though, and he’s just 2.5 years removed from a doubles-heavy Rookie of the Year runner-up campaign where he lost the crown to some Ohtani dude, who I think is a pitcher now. Weird. He’s not going to be the centerpiece in any trade, but he could easily be a supplement in a swap with another broken bench piece.
Morton will be moving at the deadline somewhere, and whoever gets him will be obtaining a winner. The only question will be whether the Braves still believe in Garcia or would prefer a hypothetical Dodgers package — but how far will Los Angeles really go for a rental?