Yankees: 3 midseason Gio Urshela trades that could work

1 of 3

Gio Urshela #29 of the New York Yankees (Photo by Steven Ryan/Getty Images) /

I don’t want to write this. But to be fair, I don’t really want to write anything about the New York Yankees these days, so there.

Odds are, unless the Yankees win every remaining game prior to the All-Star break, it seems likely they’ll end up engaging in some sort of hybrid sell-off, keeping their most essential personnel while maximizing a few of their most treasured middling assets.

So, who stays? Aaron Judge. Sorry, folks, but trading superstar position players with a year-and-a-half of control never makes the team that dealt them better. The literal best-case scenario is what the Red Sox are currently going through, and they’d still be a better team with Mookie Betts than with Alex Verdugo and his 108 OPS+.

Who goes? Well, Aroldis Chapman (any takers? ………anyone want to even talk it out?). Likely Zack Britton as well. There’s no reason to pay a high-priced reliever while stuck in this portion of the reload. The team has to entertain selling Chad Green, too — which matches the intel we received on Tuesday that the rest of the league is hottest after the righty fastball specialist, Jordan Montgomery, and Gio Urshela.

We don’t feel right saying this, but Urshela’s interesting.

Much like DJ LeMahieu, Urshela’s success in the Bronx was a happy accident. When he arrived, the Yankees’ scouting department probably thought they were getting a useful player, but not an essential cornerstone. If Urshela’s entrenched at third, and LeMahieu’s here long-term, too, then the team will have to ditch either Gleyber Torres or Luke Voit it they intend to bring in a superstar shortstop this offseason.

Or, you know, Urshela, who’s locked in through 2023 and unlikely to be extended. The Bombers probably aren’t pulling a LeMahieu again and giving extra years to a player they lucked into; part of Urshela’s value is his contract, of course.

So where does he go? Who wants a clutch, slick-fielding third baseman (who the metrics still don’t really like?) smack in the middle of his prime? Well, everyone should!

These 3 trade destinations make sense for Gio Urshela.

3. Milwaukee Brewers

Currently, the admittedly red-hot Brewers start both Jace Peterson (riding a hot streak to an unsustainable .821 OPS) and 24-year-old Luis Urias (.726 OPS) in their infield. They’re surging, but they could do better.

Urshela, just 29, has likely hit his ceiling — but that ceiling looks damn good, and as he’s proven recently, he’s maintained the versatility to slide between third base and shortstop if Willy Adames needs an off day (or to second base if the Brewers simply want to waste his talents).

A fair return for the borderline All-Star (if he were on a team other than the Yankees)? A top-10 prospect and an additional top-20 name seems fair. For Milwaukee, what about 2020 second-round shortstop Freddy Zamora (No. 8) and outfielder Tristen Lutz (No. 12)? For humor’s sake, the Yanks can also target high-upside rookie league outfielder Luis Medina (No. 13) and get a second Luis Medina in the system.

Coming up with Urshela packages is difficult, considering it involves creating a hole that must be filled by 2022 with an expensive commodity, but odds are the Yankees will be targeting young shortstop prospects as well as high-upside pitching at any level. This package fits those parameters.

Adam Duvall #14 of the Miami Marlins (Photo by Mitchell Leff/Getty Images) /

2. Slugger and Prospect From the Marlins

Want to retool and not rebuild? Maybe it’s time to give Derek Jeter a call in Miami, a team that has both big-league talent and prospects to help replenish the Yankees in a two-part deal.

When we intended to see the Yanks compete in the second half of 2021, we wanted them to cash some prospect chips in for Starling Marte, who’ll be a free agent at the end of the season. With the end of this campaign looking all but hopeless in the Bronx, though, suddenly that makes a lot less sense. Marte wants to be extended in Miami, there’s no reason to include Urshela in a short-term Marte swap. None of the parts add up.

So what about Adam Duvall? The playoff-tested slugger with the Atlanta Braves can play left or center, and comes with a mutual $5 million option for 2022. He’d give the Yankees a powerful approximation of what Hunter Renfroe gives the Red Sox, minus the cannon arm. In terms of light-tower power and versatility, though, Duvall and his league-leading 60 RBI would look better in the everyday lineup than Miguel Andújar and Clint Frazier (and Brett Gardner, and Tim Locastro…).

Though Brian Anderson is something of a local legend at third base for the Marlins, he currently resides on the 60-Day IL, and there’ll be room for Urshela to play every day moving forward in an infield that might not include Miguel Rojas next year, pending an option decision on the 32-year-old. In order to complete this trade, it’ll take a real prospect on Miami’s end — either lefty Braxton Garrett or prep southpaw Dax Fulton, their Nos. 7 and 8 guys? Either way, this could upgrade the Yankees’ outfield while paving the way for a major infield addition in 2.5 months.

German Marquez #48 of the Colorado Rockies (Photo by Dustin Bradford/Getty Images) /

1. Urshela Plus Pieces for German Marquez

OK, yes, we’re crazy for this one.

In order for the Yankees to acquire All-Star righty German Marquez, who brings with him a remarkable level of control (team option for 2024!), they’ll need to surrender significant assets. Whether they’re posturing or not, the Rockies have made it clear this will be a difficult discussion.

They’ll need a shortstop after Trevor Story walks, though, right? Potentially to the Bronx? Urshela can split short with Brendan Rodgers and play third base, while Ryan McMahon transfers to first in CJ Cron’s place, and can serve as a little MLB-level relief in what would otherwise be a pretty painful deal.

Urshela could lessen the prospect cost for the Yankees, but he obviously wouldn’t eliminate it altogether. This deal would still probably include one of Clarke Schmidt/Luis Medina/Luis Gil, depending on who the Rockies were most enraptured with, as well as fast-rising shortstop Anthony Volpe. Expect at least two top names to accompany Urshela west in this scenario, as well as a lottery ticket prospect at the lower levels.

Marquez is it, though. Still just 26, he’s mastered Coors Field to the tune of a 3.06 ERA on the season and a 3.59 mark total. He’s worse on the road! We think he could adjust to Yankee Stadium. Just intuition. Career at Coors, his 4.71 mark is far from unsightly, too.

The Rockies will want any team calling about Marquez to pay up, but if the Yankees intend to do so for a shortstop this offseason anyway, they should consider using Urshela here to make the prospect cost easier to swallow.

And yes, the Rox will probably flip Gio next summer anyway.

WASHINGTON, DC - AUGUST 22: Max Scherzer #31 of the Washington Nationals pitches in the third inning during game one of a doubleheader baseball game against the Miami Marlins at Nationals Park on August 22, 2020 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Mitchell Layton/Getty Images)

Yankees: 3 midseason trade targets fans are already itching for

New York Yankees fans, who are not enjoying this slow start whatsoever, already have their eyes on a few familiar (and not so familiar) trade targets.

Home / Yankees Rumors

These 3 trade destinations make sense for Gio Urshela.

3. Milwaukee Brewers

2. Slugger and Prospect From the Marlins

1. Urshela Plus Pieces for German Marquez

Schedule