Yankees: 3 Tigers trade targets to keep an eye on this series

SEATTLE, WASHINGTON - MAY 18: Nomar Mazara #15 and Miguel Cabrera #24 of the Detroit Tigers look on before the game against the Seattle Mariners at T-Mobile Park on May 18, 2021 in Seattle, Washington. (Photo by Steph Chambers/Getty Images)
SEATTLE, WASHINGTON - MAY 18: Nomar Mazara #15 and Miguel Cabrera #24 of the Detroit Tigers look on before the game against the Seattle Mariners at T-Mobile Park on May 18, 2021 in Seattle, Washington. (Photo by Steph Chambers/Getty Images)
1 of 3
Next

The New York Yankees were dealt a late-May gauntlet of AL East competition following their three-game set with the White Sox in the Bronx.

The Blue Jays came to town. The Rays and Red Sox (first time all year!) are booked for early June. Rev your engines and start hating your enemies! There’s no break in the action here!

Oh, but in between, the schedule-makers have sent the Yanks to Detroit for three weekend games before resuming the divisional rivalries? Thanks? No notes? Normal stuff.

Yes, for no apparent reason, the Bombers have been sent to the midwest to take on the Motor City Kitties this weekend, and that team is actually in a better place than they were the last time we met, having won nine of 11 games recently.

While playing the Tigers for the second series in a month (seriously, why?), what better time to window shop?

Last time Detroit and the Yanks locked horns (once again, this was somehow very recent!), the Bombers had an entirely different set of needs. We didn’t know if they’d have enough rotation depth to survive the season and advocated they keep an eye on Jose Ureña as a trade target, who shut them down in the final game of that set.

Might they still need a rotation upgrade, even with Luis Severino back and the starting five currently on a hot stretch? Sure. You can never have enough pitching. The need isn’t quite so dire anymore, though, and if they do get pitching, it’ll probably be a large upgrade, not a lateral move like Ureña.

No, at the moment, the screaming, blaring needs for the Yankees are outfield depth, infield depth, and versatile lefty bats. Luckily, the Tigers have a few of these pieces that could be of interest.

Also, fun side note: the Yankees actually avoid Tigers ace/trade target Matthew Boyd in this series, as he pitched Thursday’s finale against the Indians. Isn’t that fun? That hasn’t happened since the turn of the century. With that in mind, he’s been excluded from this list. You can keep an eye on him from the bench if you’d like. Watch him chew gum. 80-grade chewer.

Here’s who you should tune your attention to during the on-field action.

These 3 Yankees trade targets could come from the Detroit Tigers.

Robbie Grossman #8 of the Detroit Tigers (Photo by Kyle Rivas/Getty Images)
Robbie Grossman #8 of the Detroit Tigers (Photo by Kyle Rivas/Getty Images) /

3. Robbie Grossman

You don’t have to stretch and squint your eyes to figure out why Robbie Grossman would be an excellent trade target for the Yankees. The patient left/right/centerfielder who switch-hits basically screams relevance; he’s a younger Brett Gardner, at least offensively, and he’s already amassed 1.3 WAR this year.

Grossman’s locked down on a two-year, $10 million contract (again, helpful), and the Bombers could certainly use outfield depth next year, too, when the real Gardner might not be there to save them. Remember, the cupboard is bare. Gardner’s passable recent play has masked the fact that Estevan Florial is the only outfielder on the 40-man who isn’t currently playing for the Yankees several times a week, and there’s a third baseman/DH starting in left field most days.

A pro-rated $5 million salary for 2021 is also a perfect price tag for the money-grubbing Yanks, as long as they trade for Grossman around the All-Star break. Sporting a 129 OPS+ at the moment (his second consecutive year at that mark), the patient power threat does a lot more than just warm the throne while the rest of the outfield depth disappears. This isn’t Ryan LaMarre being promoted on a whim; this is someone who’s grown into a real winning player, one of the best scrap-heap-adjacent signings of the offseason by any middling team.

With line-drive skills gap to gap, patience and experience on a series of contenders (2015 Astros to Twins to A’s), Grossman will be the ideal addition for someone at this year’s deadline. And who needs outfielders more than we do?

Nomar Mazara #15 and Miguel Cabrera #24 of the Detroit Tigers (Photo by Steph Chambers/Getty Images)
Nomar Mazara #15 and Miguel Cabrera #24 of the Detroit Tigers (Photo by Steph Chambers/Getty Images) /

2. Nomar Mazara

Nomar Mazara’s an odd bird who’s yet to reach his potential at any stop, despite putting up superficially impressive numbers as a very young slugger in Texas.

You likely remember Mazara from being extremely annoying, slugging 20 homers a year from age 21-23 before coming up woefully short in 2019 at age 24 with only 19 bombs.

In a way, he’s very similar to previous Yankees acquisition Rougned Odor. Your perception of his skills does not quite match reality, though there’s potentially some room for growth there — after all, who among us hasn’t enjoyed Odor’s bat-flipping contributions?

Since 2019, the world hasn’t been kind to the lefty-swinging outfielder (OK, fine, the jig is up, that’s why he’s on the list in the first place). He went to Chicago for the shortened season and hit just a single homer in 42 games for the White Sox, then ended up in Detroit as a reclamation project this year, but has yet to reclaim much of anything in the season’s first few months. Though his 73 OPS+ stands out as especially woeful this season in a year without offense across the board, you’ll be surprised to know he’s never played a full season as an above-average bat. His highest OPS+ still sits at 96, a mark he’s matched twice.

In essence, we’re asking you to watch him this series to see if there’s anything you like that would differentiate him from the LaMarres and Delino DeShields of the world. He’ll be very available.

Harold Castro #30 of the Detroit Tigers (Photo by Duane Burleson/Getty Images)
Harold Castro #30 of the Detroit Tigers (Photo by Duane Burleson/Getty Images) /

1. Harold Castro

Harold Castro, a curiosity, is for sure hitting the baseball well in 2021. As he did in 2020. As he did in 2019.

The Tigers will have to decide whether or not he’s somebody they believe will be on the next great team in Detroit, though, or whether they’d rather sell him at something that looks like his peak.

Truth be told, Castro is probably not a starting infielder on a championship-caliber team considering his stark lack of power. Luckily, that’s not what the Yankees need, though. They need a roving slap hitter who can fill in occasionally and whip singles from the left side of the plate, and that’s exactly what Castro provides.

Following a .347 average and 130 OPS+ in just 22 games last season, he’s replicated that average thus far in 2021, hitting .351 through 26 games without a home run — though he did run into five baseballs in 2019, his only campaign approximating a full season. Under control for a minuscule price through 2025, the 27-year-old Venezuelan might fill a nice roving role once played by Thairo Estrada in the Bronx. Perhaps he might do well next to Gleyber “De Caracas” Torres at second? He’s also spent time at third, first, short, and across the outfield, pocketing singular bases wherever he floats.

Truly, we have … no idea how to estimate Castro’s prospect cost. Of course the Tigers like him, but we’re not sure how they could value him the same way you’d value, say, a proven power bat or an infielder who hasn’t reached his ceiling yet. Castro seems destined to wind up playing an important role as the 25th man on a good team rather than a starter asked to carry the water on a struggling group, and as long as it wouldn’t require any prospect in their top 15, the Yankees should be interested.

Next