If not for the New York Yankees routing the Detroit Tigers 10-0 on Friday night, perhaps this would have been a bigger story.
In the top of the fourth inning, after striking out the first two batters, Cole had an 0-2 count on Jonathan Schoop. The right-hander tried to blow a fastball by him, but Schoop took it to left field.
Was it catchable? Perhaps, if Clint Frazier made a really good read right off the bat and made a diving grab. But we don’t really know what he was doing here.
Frazier gingerly approached the ball with his glove in the air as if he was battling the sun (?), played the ball on a hop, and then, once again, fired his throw into no man’s land.
Cole? Not entirely happy. At least based on his body language.
It’s possible Cole was simply mad at himself for allowing the single, but many on social media seem to think he was expressing frustration with Frazier, who has done this before while the Yankees’ ace was on the mound.
Cole about to ask for a personal left fielder as well pic.twitter.com/2L7NpNuqqt
— Jomboy (@Jomboy_) May 1, 2021
Can we just hit the cut-off man, Clint? One time?
Remember this play from earlier in the month? Almost the exact same thing.
I genuinely thought Gerrit Cole was going to chuck this ball back out to Clint Frazier pic.twitter.com/GzxCihLFDq
— Brent Maguire (@bmags94) April 18, 2021
This was a Gold Glove nominee in 2020. And it’s been a really rough start for Frazier on defense in 2021 … a season in which he was named the starting left field in spring training.
With the way Cole has been pitching — he’s been making history after just six outings — it wouldn’t be surprising at all if he’s not accepting anything less than heads-up and all-out defensive performances. And a guy like Frazier, who’s shaky on defense and isn’t exactly regarded as a mistake-free, locked-in teammate, certainly isn’t an ideal defender to have behind you.
Gerrit Cole's irritation level with Clint Frazier is pretty remarkable considering we're not even through April yet. https://t.co/DyGGIhzHyU
— Kyle Glaser (@KyleAGlaser) May 1, 2021
Judge for yourself. Also … how deep is Frazier playing here? Schoop isn’t exactly a fearsome power hitter. Was that Frazier’s doing or the Yankees’ defensive alignment?
Again, really not sure, but Frazier’s play coupled with Cole’s body language didn’t make for a good pairing.
Gerrit Cole's reaction to Clint Frazier trying to fool runners with no one on base then overthrowing two infielders 😂 pic.twitter.com/3rsJaf4EpT
— Baseball Doesn't Exist (@BaseballDoesnt) May 1, 2021
And to kick off Saturday? Frazier dropped a fly ball and made an error on the first batter of the game.
The Yankees are going to have to do something about his defense — specifically his awareness — if he’s going to be a starting outfielder.

Yankees: Gerrit Cole is hell-bent on winning a Cy Young award
New York Yankees ace (it feels good to say that!) Gerrit Cole has been running train on the rest of MLB and he's ready to win a Cy Young award.